Could Indy Eleven Really Win the U.S. Open Cup?

Soccer in the U.S. always has a way of keeping us on our toes. And right now, the biggest surprise is coming out of Indy Eleven. A USL Championship team that’s proving heart and hustle still count more than a flashy name. In a tournament where MLS giants usually run the show, who would’ve thought a smaller-budget club would be marching its way to the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup semifinals?

Nobody really expected much from Indy Eleven when they first hit the pitch back in the third round against Chicago Fire FC II. But with a 1-0 win over Chicago Fire II, Indy Eleven started showing that they weren’t just there to be part of the background noise.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

That win was their calling card, but most folks didn’t really take it seriously. After all, beating an MLS reserve squad doesn’t exactly scream “big deal,” right? But as the rounds rolled on, Indy Eleven began building a story that was hard to ignore. Then came the matchup against San Antonio FC, and Indy had no trouble brushing off the Texans with a solid 2-0 win.

Then came the real challenge: facing Atlanta United—a team that’s got the respect and reputation as one of the MLS powerhouses. For many, this was supposed to be the end of the line for Indy Eleven. But nope, they pulled off yet another shocker, taking down Atlanta 2-1 and securing their spot in the semifinals for the first time ever.

Now, the next chapter of this wild ride takes them to Sporting Kansas City. Indy’s heading to Children’s Mercy Park knowing that, once again, the odds are stacked against them. But if there’s one thing this team’s journey has proven, it’s that they really don’t care about the odds. They’re here to play ball, bleed for every inch, and leave the field with a W.

In an era where everything seems to revolve around big bucks, multi-million dollar contracts, and players with rockstar status, Indy Eleven’s out there reminding us that you can still find quality players in smaller clubs. Their fans? Passionate, even though they’re not packing out stadiums like MLS crowds. They may be fewer, but they’re just as fiery.

The Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup is one of those tournaments where anything can happen. It’s got that same charm as national cups around the globe, where the underdogs get their chance to shine against the heavyweights. Indy Eleven is writing their own story right now, and honestly, there’s nothing more thrilling in sports than seeing the little guy flipping the script.

Indy Eleven had faced MLS teams before and always came up short. So, what’s changed? Maybe it’s the squad’s maturity. Maybe it’s the coach. Maybe it’s just the stars aligning at the right time. It’s probably a mix of all that, but most of all, it’s their grit that’s making the difference.

Now, everyone’s got their eyes on this next clash with Sporting Kansas City. SKC’s got history, they’ve got the infrastructure, they’ve got the fans. But so what? Indy Eleven has already shown they don’t get rattled by any of that. They play with the freedom of a team that’s got nothing to lose, and that kind of mindset can be a real ace in the hole in tournaments like this.

If you ask me, Sporting Kansas City should be worried. Sure, they’re the favorites, but being the favorite doesn’t win games. And Indy Eleven? Well, they’ve got a real shot at pulling off another surprise.

So, do they have what it takes to lift the trophy? Look, I wouldn’t bet against them at this point. They’ve already proven they’ve got more than just guts; they’ve got the skills and the game plan to back it up. If they manage to knock off Sporting Kansas City, then yeah, the dream is alive, and the finals will be right there, waiting for another twist in this story.

If I were you, I’d keep an eye on them. It’s clear now that Indy Eleven isn’t just that team flying under the radar anymore. They could very well be the Cinderella story of the season. Oh, and don’t forget—the game’s free to watch on MLS Season Pass on Apple TV.