Against All Odds and Under Pressure, Indy Eleven Makes History in the U.S. Open Cup

Who would've guessed? Indy Eleven, a team from the USL Championship, is just one step away from playing in the final of the 2024 U.S. Open Cup. It's like something straight out of a Hollywood script: the team nobody would bet a dime on, defying all the odds and on the verge of making history. But this isn’t some feel-good movie—it’s real, raw, and full of sweat, tears, and just a touch of magic.

Indy Eleven kicked off 2024 in a way that would make even the most die-hard fan want to throw in the towel. One win in seven games. Yep, just one. It was supposed to be the end, right? Wrong. Then came the rumors that Indianapolis might land an MLS team. That meant the Eleven players suddenly had a giant shadow looming over them—the threat of losing their jobs, just like what happened to the San Diego Loyal. Who can handle that kind of pressure? Instead of collapsing under the weight of it all, they took those sour lemons and turned them into the sweetest lemonade. Now, they're in the semifinals of the oldest club competition in the U.S. Not many teams can say that.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

What seemed like a bleak situation actually became fuel. Coach Sean McAuley had the good sense to gather the group and tell them what they needed to hear: forget MLS, forget the uncertainties—focus on what you can control. And somehow, that message clicked in their heads. How did Indy Eleven flip the switch and go from such a rough start to challenging the big boys? The answer lies in a perfect mix of resilience, strategy, and a big dose of “let’s shut everyone up.”

Soccer's a sport where the biggest budget and most famous players don’t always win. And the U.S. Open Cup is the shining example of that. It’s the kind of tournament where the so-called “small” clubs get their shot at playing giant for a day. Indy Eleven has embraced that spirit like few others. Sure, they’re not the first second-division side to get this far, but their story is fascinating. The hurdles that should’ve knocked them down became their greatest strength. Maybe it’s irony, maybe it’s destiny, but it’s real as can be. And it’s happening at a time when soccer in the U.S. is shifting, with MLS growing, more money flowing in, and more attention from fans. In a scene like that, the potential arrival of an MLS team to Indy should’ve been a distraction. Instead, it became motivation.

Enter Augustine “Augi” Williams. This guy’s the beating heart of the squad, the type of player who embodies the spirit of Indy Eleven. Williams knows what it’s like to face the uncertainty of a club shutting its doors; he’s been through it with the San Diego Loyal. He could’ve let it break him, but, as he put it, the only thing he can control is how he plays. And what a performance it’s been! Three goals and an assist in four U.S. Open Cup matches so far. The guy’s just decided nothing’s gonna stop him from shining, not even facing teams from a superior league like MLS.

Now, sure, some might say luck played a role. Ah, the old “they had an easy path to the semifinals” line. But that narrative falls apart when you remember they knocked out Atlanta United, one of MLS’s big boys. And it wasn’t some fluke victory—it was built, planned, and deserved. To top it off, Williams led the charge, which made that win even sweeter. So let’s drop the idea that Indy Eleven had it easy. This team earned its place.

Coach McAuley knows the game’s ruthless to both favorites and underdogs alike. But he also gets that what’s driving this squad isn’t just the hunger to win—it’s something deeper. It’s the need to prove they belong at this level, even when everyone around them is doubting. It’s the same fire that pushes a regular guy to fight against the system, refusing to back down when life throws obstacle after obstacle at him.

As they prepare to face Sporting Kansas City in the semifinals, one thing’s for sure: no matter the outcome, Indy Eleven has already made history. They’re living proof that sometimes all you need is a spark. And when that spark hits the right fuel, the fire it creates can take down even the strongest opponents. Whether they’ll grab the ultimate glory or not, we don’t know yet. But one thing’s certain—they’re teaching us that we’re the ones who get to decide how we respond when adversity strikes.