Indy Eleven One Step Away from Concacaf Championship While Competing in the USL

What started as a typical U.S. Open Cup run is quickly turning into a fairy tale for Indy Eleven. A team that, let’s be honest, wasn’t exactly on anyone’s radar when it came to making a deep run. But now, thanks to an unexpected twist in the competition, this Indianapolis squad is just one breath—or more precisely, one win—away from a coveted spot in the Concacaf Champions Cup. Yep, that’s right! The same tournament that usually feels reserved for the continent's soccer elites, like the powerhouse MLS clubs or the dominant Mexican sides. But here they are, Indy Eleven, lurking just around the corner.

It feels like fiction, but it’s very much real. If LAFC secures their Champions Cup spot through the Leagues Cup and also makes it to the U.S. Open Cup final, Indy Eleven could snag a once-in-a-lifetime chance to qualify as the runner-up. But of course, there’s a massive roadblock in their way: Sporting Kansas City. And let’s be clear, this isn’t just any opponent. SKC has earned its reputation as a tough-as-nails MLS side.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Indy Eleven, who until recently wasn’t even in the conversation for international competitions, now finds itself in the company of clubs that have shattered that ceiling before. Think Puerto Rico Islanders, Vancouver Whitecaps, and Montreal Impact. The sheer possibility of Indy Eleven joining this elite group of underdog heroes is what makes this story so compelling. If it happens, it won’t just be a victory for the club, but for the entire USL. Let’s be real—teams from this league don’t often get this far. But what does that mean in practical terms? Well, for starters, it’s a golden opportunity for the club to prove its worth on the international stage. Not just to show they can go toe-to-toe with the big boys, but also to catch the eye of investors and fans alike.

Of course, from a practical standpoint, this opportunity brings some serious challenges. Playing in the Concacaf Champions Cup isn’t for the faint of heart. It means going up against the best teams in North America, Central America, and the Caribbean—many of whom boast way better infrastructure, deeper rosters, and way bigger budgets than Indy Eleven. Let’s be honest here. The odds of a USL team making it to the U.S. Open Cup final and qualifying for the Concacaf Champions Cup is, without a doubt, a freak occurrence. But, ironically, it’s exactly this kind of anomaly that keeps the heart of soccer beating strong. It’s these unpredictable, against-all-odds stories that keep fans believing. Who would’ve thought, for instance, that Leicester City would win the Premier League in the 2015-16 season? Exactly. Just like Leicester stunned England’s rich and powerful, Indy Eleven might just be on the brink of challenging the giants of continental soccer. They’re standing in a position few clubs have ever been in.

If Indy Eleven does manage to clinch this spot, it’ll be more than just a victory for the club—it’ll be a triumph for every lower-league team fighting to prove their worth in a system dominated by MLS. Regardless of how this shakes out, Indy Eleven has already made history by getting this far.