Indy Eleven's Holding Strong, Even When Wins Slip Away in the Details

Indy Eleven is going through one of those transition phases every soccer club, big or small, has to face sooner or later. If you take a look at their numbers and recent performances, you'll see a team fighting tooth and nail to stay competitive, yet still figuring out its true identity in an increasingly tough landscape. The last game against Las Vegas Lights FC was a textbook example of this.

So, let’s kick off with Jack Blake, the midfielder who made a comeback after two months on the sidelines, immediately making his presence known. He's the kind of player you can feel on the field, even when he’s not on the ball. Blake was the conductor in the match against Las Vegas. His first pass found Sebastian Guenzatti, who didn’t hesitate for a second before putting it in the back of the net. And that wasn’t all. Like a true artist, Blake dazzled again 22 minutes later with a quick touch that set Elliot Collier up for the perfect finish. That’s no small feat. A player returning from a long absence and immediately changing the pace of the game deserves the spotlight. And let’s be real, this is the kind of leadership Indy Eleven needs right now.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Blake’s performance is a prime example of how a team can be sparked by a single player coming back hungry and determined to make a difference. But even with this individual spark, Indy Eleven’s got a few cracks that need to be filled. And yeah, nobody likes talking about flaws, but they’re right there, clear as day. The defense, for instance, has shown signs of fatigue. The goals they gave up to Las Vegas Lights are proof that no matter how much the attack delivers, there are holes in the back that need patching up. This became painfully obvious when Indy conceded a third goal almost immediately after tying the game. Lack of focus? Maybe. But the bottom line is, even with Blake doing the heavy lifting in midfield, the team as a whole needs to tighten up.

That said, it’s not all doom and gloom. There are some positives, and you can’t just ignore them. Sebastian Guenzatti, with his 75th USL goal, hit a major milestone. He’s now one of the league’s all-time greats, and his name’s etched in the history books. Guenzatti’s been a steady force in attack, and even though Indy Eleven’s been struggling, he’s kept pushing the team forward. Plus, he’s got a solid partnership with Augi Williams, who’s also on the list of top USL scorers. These two are a dynamic duo, shouldering a big chunk of the offensive load.

And speaking of hope, Elliot Collier’s another name worth mentioning. He might not have Guenzatti’s history, but his impact in the limited chances he’s had this season is undeniable. His fourth goal of the year, scored against Las Vegas, was one of those smart striker goals—the kind where the guy shows up at the right moment and gets the job done. Collier’s proving he deserves more minutes on the field, and maybe that’s exactly the kind of tactical shift Indy’s coach needs to consider. Soccer’s funny like that; sometimes the answer is right where you least expect it.

They’ve already shown they can hang with the bigger teams. Their five away wins this season prove that. In fact, they’re the first USL team to hit that mark in 2024, which is a pretty big deal. The problem is, the wins aren’t coming as often as the fans would like, especially at home. And that inconsistency could end up costing them big.

We’ve got to acknowledge that Indy Eleven’s in a transitional phase. They started the season with a streak of 15 games scoring goals, but things have cooled off since then. Some of that can be chalked up to injuries and the natural wear and tear of a long season, but there’s something deeper going on here too. Maybe the team’s dealing with a bit of an identity crisis. They’ve got talent, no doubt about it. But talent without direction? It doesn’t get you far. And that’s the challenge the coach and team leaders need to tackle head-on.

But let’s not forget, there’s still a lot of soccer left to play this season, and Indy Eleven’s got time to regroup and make a playoff push. They want to see their team transform into a true contender, not just surviving in the league but really gunning for the title. And honestly, Indy Eleven’s got the potential to do just that.

With Jack Blake back in form, Guenzatti leading the charge, and Collier making the most of his chances, there’s reason to be optimistic. If Indy Eleven can fix their mistakes, they just might surprise everyone.