With Berhalter in Charge, Will the Chicago Fire Rise or Sink for Good?

It's been a long time since Chicago Fire basked in glory. Seven years without tasting the MLS playoffs, and even though the fans' passion hasn't wavered, the club's been dimmer than a burnt-out bulb. Enter Gregg Berhalter, former USMNT coach, stepping onto the stage to change that story. But can he really pull it off?

Gregg Berhalter’s got experience; no one doubts that. He took Columbus Crew to the MLS Cup Final in 2015 and led the U.S. Men’s National Team through some rough times. But let’s be real, his name’s been in headlines for less-than-great reasons lately. That Copa América disaster, which led to his departure from the national team, left a bad taste in everyone's mouth. Still, Berhalter seems to have found new fire (pun intended) in Chicago, a team that, in owner Joe Mansueto’s words, is a "sleeping giant."

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

The strategy is clear: turn the Fire into one of MLS's top teams, and fast. Berhalter’s not one to take a slow and steady approach; he’s already made it clear he doesn’t have the patience for a five-year plan. The pressure to win now is everywhere.

Berhalter wants to build a player-first club. Sounds cliché, right? I mean, what team doesn’t want to maximize its players’ potential? But here’s the thing, he’s serious about it. He’s talking about bringing in players who rank among the top 5% in the league, true "game changers." Sounds great on paper, but can he actually deliver on that?

MLS doesn't exactly have the pull of Europe’s top leagues, and elite players aren't lining up to come play in the States. Berhalter knows that, but he’s convinced the Fire’s got the resources to make big moves and turn things around.

Speaking of big promises, Mansueto also let slip that the Fire are exploring building their own stadium within city limits. That’d be a real game changer for the club. Since moving back to Soldier Field, home of the NFL’s Bears, the dream of a soccer-specific stadium has been a distant hope. Now, it looks like that dream could get a little more real. But finding the right spot in Chicago? Yeah, not easy, and Mansueto knows it. Still, the thought of their own stadium is the cherry on top of a project aiming to make the Fire one of MLS's elite.

But doesn't all this sound a little... too ambitious? Berhalter and Mansueto talk about big plans, but what the Fire really needs is a clear identity on the field. Back in his Columbus Crew days, Berhalter was praised for building a tactically disciplined, organized team, something the Fire hasn’t seen in a while. The big question is: can he do the same in Chicago, especially with the pressure for quick results hanging over him?

And let’s not forget about the emotional baggage Berhalter’s carrying. He’s openly admitted that his time with the USMNT ended in a gut punch. He even compared it to a grieving process, something that shook his confidence and forced him to do some deep soul-searching about his career. But maybe that time of reflection is what’s giving him the renewed energy to take on the challenge at Chicago Fire. In a league where coaches come and go like leaves in the wind, it’s refreshing to see Berhalter go "all in," as Mansueto put it, from day one. It’s a sliver of hope for a fanbase that’s gotten used to disappointment.

One interesting twist in this new chapter for the Fire is the amount of control Berhalter’s going to have. He’s not just the head coach, he’s also the club’s sporting director. That means he’s in charge of not only how the team plays but also who plays. It’s a rare, but not unheard-of, setup in MLS. Peter Vermes at Sporting Kansas City holds the same dual role. On one hand, Berhalter’s got complete control over the project, so if things go right, he’ll be the hero. On the flip side, if it all goes south, there’s no one else to share the blame.

Obviously, the Chicago Fire are far from an easy fix. The team’s been inconsistent, the last few seasons have been disappointing, and MLS is a league where unpredictability is the only constant. But with Berhalter at the helm and an owner willing to spend, there’s definitely a light at the end of the tunnel.