The MLS Trophy Nobody Knows About

Major League Soccer has grown – and not by just a little. From those early days with small crowds and bare-bones setups to the grand spectacle we see now, the league has transformed so dramatically it’s almost like a movie script. At the heart of it all, like a mystical emblem of this journey, is the MLS Cup trophy: the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy.

Yeah, it’s the trophy you see held high by champions each year; that explosion of cheers, tears, and golden confetti flying everywhere. But what many don’t know is that behind that grand moment, the road to that stage is packed with history, tributes, and name changes, and even a few design makeovers that make it more than just a shiny thing to hold up at the end of the season.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Anschutz – the man whose name graces the trophy – was one of those rare visionaries. Without him, his cash, his influence, and, of course, his passion for the game, MLS might not be anywhere close to what it is today. He poured millions into the league when nobody really believed soccer could make it big in the States.

Before the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy, the league handed out the Alan I. Rothenberg Trophy, which was the first to be awarded to MLS champions. And Alan I. Rothenberg was no small figure either. He was one of the first to realize that, for soccer to really catch on in the U.S., there had to be a solid league with competitive teams and a professional structure that could pull American fans in. His vision is what gave MLS that first push it needed to survive, endure, and grow. The original trophy in his name was awarded in the league’s first three years – a symbol that, even though it's been replaced, still remains in history as the league’s first icon.

Back then, this first trophy, with its two handles surrounding a dark golden soccer ball, represented a try at bringing tradition to a sport that was just beginning to capture American hearts. In 1999, the trophy got a redesign; now it had a soccer ball on top of a goal post, making it more like the classic symbols seen in other leagues. This look stuck until 2008, when the trophy was renamed to honor Anschutz, marking a new era in MLS, an era where soccer was finally starting to catch real momentum in the United States.

This trophy isn’t just some hunk of metal; it’s almost like a family heirloom passed down from champion to champion, adding stories, memories, and even a few scratches and marks from past battles. It’s a bridge linking MLS’s past to its present, between those who believed in the sport during tough times and the ones now reaping the rewards of its rise.

When you think about it, calling the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy a “modern fossil” isn’t far off – it’s an artifact that logs the history of a sport that defied the odds and won over a country that, for so long, was all about football, basketball, and baseball. It wasn’t easy. Each victory holds echoes of the people like Rothenberg and Anschutz, who believed when almost no one else did. And, in a way, those victories are relived every time a new team climbs that podium and hoists the trophy with pride.