The start of Major League Soccer was a bold leap for soccer in the U.S. It was a time of big dreams and risky bets; every match seemed like a life-or-death struggle. No one embodied this new era better than D.C. United—a team that didn’t just play soccer but etched its name in history right from the start. United wasn’t just a winning team; it shaped the DNA of MLS, setting the tone and showing what was possible.
The debut MLS Cup in 1996 was the kind of thriller every fan dreams of: tension, comebacks, and, of course, a victory right out of a Hollywood script. When the LA Galaxy scored twice, their celebration felt inevitable; the Californian team seemed to have it in the bag. But United wasn’t ready to bow out. That’s when Tony Sanneh lit the spark of hope, scoring with just 18 minutes left. As if the drama weren’t thick enough, the clock ticked down to the wire when Shawn Medved tied it, sending the game into overtime. And then, like magic, Eddie Pope sealed the win with a golden goal.
Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).
In 1997, D.C. United came back hungry for more. This time, they took center stage at RFK Stadium, packed with fans ready to witness another historic victory. And they didn’t leave disappointed. With a 2-1 win over the Colorado Rapids, United claimed its place as the first team to win back-to-back MLS Cups. Jaime Moreno, the game’s star, capped off the match with a decisive goal, proving that United wasn’t just in it for wins; they were in it to leave a legacy of quality and spirit.
These D.C. United victories weren’t just trophies; they were declarations that American soccer could compete among the sports giants of the U.S. With the Supporters’ Shield also in their hands, United showed they could dominate the regular season and the MLS Cup in one sweep—a feat so monumental that it took a decade for another team to pull it off.
The 1998 season, though, served a bitter dose of reality. Not every story ends in fairy tales, and United learned that the hard way when they lost to Chicago Fire in the MLS Cup, 2-0. It felt like the end of an unstoppable era. But, like a phoenix, United rose again the next year and returned to the finals to face the Galaxy once more. It was a clean, no-doubt victory, with United winning 2-0 and capturing another Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup.
But D.C. United’s impact goes beyond stats and trophies. It’s about how they showed the American audience that soccer could pack the same thrill as baseball or football. Each United match felt like a must-watch event. In a time when MLS was still finding its footing, United gave the league the credibility and spectacle it desperately needed.
What D.C. United achieved in that period set the bar. Other clubs realized that winning in MLS took more than just talented players; it required a fierce spirit, a winning mentality. That mentality became an MLS symbol, and to this day, we see United’s mark in teams that play every match as if it’s a final.
Over time, other teams came along and made their own marks. But nothing erases the fact that D.C. United was the pioneer, blazing the trail and making MLS glory possible. United proved that MLS wasn’t just a second-rate league; it was a league worth paying attention to, one that could capture American hearts. Today, D.C. United still carries the weight of its own history.