Who’s Really Playing Better in the Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo Duel Outside of Europe?

It’s almost poetic watching Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo, two of the brightest stars in modern soccer, continuing to rewrite their stories even after leaving the main stage in Europe. While many thought their exit from the Old Continent would mark the beginning of the end, they’re proving they’ve still got plenty left in the tank. And the question on every soccer fan’s mind around the world is: Who’s standing out more in this new phase? Who, between Messi and CR7, still holds the title of the world’s best away from Europe’s pitches?

Let’s be real here, Lionel Messi’s choice to join Inter Miami was, at the very least, surprising. He could’ve gone anywhere. Europe was at his feet, the Middle East was waving cash at him, and yet, he decided to head to the MLS. Bold move? Absolutely. But Messi isn’t just anyone. He quickly turned North American soccer into a spectacle like never before. Inter Miami used to be just another team in a league fighting for respect, but now, with Messi on the field, they’re Hollywood-worthy. And Messi didn’t disappoint: 25 goals and 16 assists in 29 matches, numbers that would make even the skeptics blink twice. It’s like Messi’s playing a video game, dribbling and scoring as if it’s the easiest thing in the world.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Oh, and let’s not forget his debut story, where Messi scored the decisive goal against Cruz Azul in the 2023 Leagues Cup, almost as if saying, “I’m here, and I’m here to conquer.” He led Inter Miami to their first significant title, showing the world that his hunger for trophies is far from over. As if that wasn’t enough, he finished the tournament as the top scorer, was named the best player, and lifted the cup. It might sound like a movie script, but this is just Messi being Messi. The simplicity of his touch on the ball, the precision in his finishes—all of it reminds us why he’s regarded as the greatest of all time. And to top off this phase of his career, FIFA awarded him his eighth Best Player in the World title. Eight times!

But while Messi dazzles under Miami’s sunny beaches, Cristiano Ronaldo is continuing his saga in the Arabian desert, where he’s living out his own personal epic. Al Nassr knew exactly what they were doing when they signed the Portuguese star. Cristiano isn’t just a player, he’s a marketing machine, a global superstar, and above all, a legend who always wants more. If Messi is a poet on the field, Ronaldo is a gladiator, fighting to the end for every title, every goal.

Since arriving at Al Nassr, CR7 has been a colossus. He’s racked up 66 goals and 16 assists in 72 games, numbers that make even Europe’s elite strikers look like amateurs. In his first game, a modest win, but what followed was a festival of goals that only Ronaldo can deliver. He shattered records, scored hat-tricks as if it was routine, and even lifted the Arab Champions League trophy. And then comes that classic scene: Cristiano, smiling and holding the trophy high with the same determination as always, showing that the fire that has always defined him is still burning strong.

While Messi seems to have embraced a lighter, more artistic phase, dominating without pressure, CR7 still appears to be driven by an unrelenting force, almost as if he always has something to prove. Messi, with his graceful dribbles and magical plays, feels like a maestro conducting his final symphony, while Cristiano is the warrior in his final battle, refusing to give an inch.

But does dominance in less competitive leagues diminish the value of these accomplishments? Some might argue that it does, especially when comparing MLS or the Saudi league to the Premier League or La Liga. But that’s overly simplistic. If it were easy, everyone would be doing what Messi and Cristiano are doing. Sure, the level of competition may be different, but the pressure and the global scrutiny remain just as intense. At the end of the day, the greatness of these two players transcends leagues, countries, and continents. No matter where they play, they’re shaping soccer in their own image.

Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo have long surpassed the “best player in the world” label and entered the realm of legends. What they’re doing now is more than just racking up stats—they’re defining how the final chapter of their careers will be remembered. Sure, there will always be debates about who’s better. But maybe the answer is simpler than we think: Messi and Ronaldo are two sides of the same coin. One is the sublime artist, the other, the immortal warrior. They’re above the rest, and as much as we try to compare their achievements, the truth is, each one is writing their own legend in a way only they know how.