Which Indy Eleven Players Brought the Heat to Sporting KC in the U.S. Open Cup?

When you think of soccer in the U.S., teams like LA Galaxy or Seattle Sounders probably pop into your head first. But hold up! Let’s give some love to a team that’s making some noise in the 2024 U.S. Open Cup: Indy Eleven. Now, they might not be front-page news or packing massive stadiums, but trust me, they’re turning heads, and there are a few players you’re gonna want to keep an eye on.

First up, let’s talk about Augi Williams. This guy is lethal in front of goal and already has three goals to his name in this tournament. Nothing demands respect more than a player who knows how to put the ball in the back of the net. Williams is not playing around. He’s like that quiet striker who doesn’t seem like much of a threat until—bam—the defense slips up, and he’s already got one in. He might not be the most famous forward out there, but that’s what makes him so dangerous. You don’t see him coming until it’s too late.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Sometimes, the real magic is in creating chances. That’s where Aedan Stanley steps in. He’s been dishing out those crucial assists that keep the team running like a well-oiled machine. Stanley’s already bagged two assists in this U.S. Open Cup, and sure, that might not sound like a ton, but his plays are sneaky dangerous. He knows how to position himself, he sees those little pockets of space, and his passes throw defenders off. It’s like he’s the conductor of an orchestra, directing the squad while everyone else tries to keep up with the beat.

Now, when it comes to firing shots, Douglas Martinez is your guy. Seven shots so far, and he’s showing that when the team needs someone to test the keeper or take a chance from distance, he’s the man for the job. He might not have scored as much as Williams, but the sheer number of attempts speaks for itself: he’s relentless. Martinez isn’t letting up the pressure. He’s that player who just won’t quit, who keeps hammering away until the ball finally finds the net. And hey, sometimes that persistence is exactly what makes the difference between winning and losing.

And to round out the list of players carrying Indy Eleven on their backs, we’ve gotta talk about Hunter Sulte, the goalkeeper. Ever heard of a “brick wall”? That’s Sulte. When the offense can’t finish the job, he’s there to bail them out. With 13 saves so far in the tournament, he’s proving that he’s not just some background character. Let’s be real, having a reliable keeper is essential for any team dreaming of making a deep run in a competition like this. Sulte’s not just doing the basics; he’s going above and beyond. You get the sense that he’s always in the right place at the right time, with the calm confidence of someone who already knows what’s coming.

It’s this blend of talent that’s putting Indy Eleven on the map in the U.S. Open Cup. How far can they go? Will these guys just be a nice surprise in the 2024 U.S. Open Cup, or do they actually have what it takes to take that next step and become a real force in American soccer? It’s tough to say for sure, but if what they’ve shown so far is a preview of what’s to come, the other teams better start paying attention.

Of course, we can’t ignore the fact that the U.S. Open Cup is full of surprises. Everybody loves a good underdog story—the team that sneaks up out of nowhere and takes down the giants. Could Indy Eleven be that team? Could they be the dark horses who ride all the way to the end and make history? I mean, sure, it might sound like a stretch, but hey, why not dream big?

What’s clear right now is that Indy Eleven is building a reputation for showing up when it counts. You don’t see a smaller club making this kind of impact in a major tournament every day. With Williams leading the charge, Stanley carving out opportunities, Martinez peppering the opposition's goal, and Sulte holding it down in the back, they’ve got all the pieces to keep on surprising people.