Toronto FC Fumbles the Transfer Window

Toronto FC approached this transfer window with a laundry list of needs. The team desperately needed reinforcements across several key positions— a quality central midfielder, a clinical number 9 to ease the pressure up top, and of course, a starting-caliber center-back. But as the window slammed shut, all we witnessed was a series of missteps and missed opportunities.

Expectations were sky-high, and rightly so. Toronto FC has long been built on a strong foundation, with players capable of shining in Major League Soccer (MLS). But what unfolded was nothing short of disappointing. Not only did the club fail to address its most critical gaps, but they also let another one of their young stars slip through their fingers. That’s exactly what happened with Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty, a homegrown prodigy who packed his bags for CF Montréal.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Sure, Marshall-Rutty’s transfer brought in a hefty fee—one of the largest ever received for a homegrown MLS player. But, let's be real, championships aren't won with cash alone. The kid was one of the club's brightest prospects, and his departure left an emotional crater as big as the hole in their defense. Yes, they brought in Henry Wingo, a seasoned and versatile player, but that’s not enough to wash away the stains left from this window.

Toronto needed so much more. The lack of a high-caliber central midfielder feels like that gaping hole in the middle of the field that everyone sees, yet no one fixes. Without a true playmaker, the game is slow, stagnant, almost a shadow of what a competitive MLS team should be. And without a legitimate number 9, the pressure on Prince Owusu and Federico Bernardeschi just keeps mounting. Sure, they’re solid players, but come on—they can’t carry the team on their own. The squad needs more pieces to complete the puzzle.

Toronto FC has always been known for its strong academy, a breeding ground for talent that fed into the first team. Now, they’re selling off their future stars for what feels like a handful of coins while neglecting the present needs. It’s almost as if the team has stopped looking forward, stuck in a loop of poor management and questionable decisions. Wingo might help plug some holes in the defense, but he’s not going to carry the team on his back. The void in the midfield remains, and without a true number 9, the attack is toothless.

If the team keeps going down this road, without fixing these glaring mistakes, the writing’s on the wall—a mediocre season is coming. And let’s face it, that’s not what the fans want. They want to see a competitive team, a squad that fights for trophies, not one that settles for less.