Time to Say Goodbye? Braithwaite Could Swap Grêmio for MLS

Martin Braithwaite came to Grêmio with all the fanfare of a superstar, but it looks like his romance with the Brazilian fans is crashing down faster than you can say, "missed goal." The Danish striker, who was brought in to fill Diego Costa's shoes (you know, the guy who used to play for Chelsea and Atlético Madrid), barely set foot in Brazil before feeling the heat of the criticism. And honestly, it’s not hard to see why. But could the next chapter of this drama be written in Major League Soccer (MLS)?

Let's backtrack a bit. Braithwaite, formerly of Barcelona, landed in Porto Alegre as the big hope for a Grêmio team searching for its groove. The problem? The honeymoon was over before it even started. After a lackluster performance against Criciúma, where he missed a sitter and got subbed in the second half, the fans didn’t hold back. Social media, always quick to the trigger, turned the Dane into the punching bag of the week.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Here's the thing—Grêmio isn't just any team. The pressure is intense, the expectations are constant, and let's be real, the fans' patience has a pretty short fuse. When Braithwaite flopped on the basics, the trust they had in him started to crumble. And that ghost of a performance in Grêmio’s elimination from the Libertadores against Fluminense (yeah, the same Fluminense where Marcelo, the ex-Real Madrid star, and Thiago Silva, who played for Milan, PSG, and Chelsea, currently play) didn’t help either. From there, it’s tough to see him turning this around without some sort of miracle.

And this is where MLS enters the picture. American soccer might just be the perfect landing spot for a guy like Braithwaite. In the land of second chances, he’d have the opportunity to hit the reset button, far from the critical eyes and relentless demands of Grêmio fans. Plus, MLS has a bit of a rep for breathing new life into the careers of players who, for one reason or another, didn’t quite make it in Europe or other top leagues. And let’s be honest, the pressure in MLS is a lot less intense than it is in Brazil.

But is Braithwaite really ready to give up on the Brazilian dream? And more importantly, is MLS truly the sanctuary he’s looking for? If we take a look at the league’s recent track record, it’s clear that it’s becoming an increasingly attractive destination for big-name players. All of them found a second wind in the States. The mix of competitive soccer, a less grueling schedule, and the chance to live in vibrant cities like New York, San Diego, and Orlando, among others, is pretty tempting, to say the least. Still, moving to MLS isn’t a guaranteed win. Braithwaite would need to adapt to a different style of play, a new culture, and, of course, the fact that in the U.S., he’d be seen as a marquee signing, which brings its own set of pressures. It’d be a fresh start, sure, but with new challenges.

On the flip side, Grêmio has to weigh its options too. Keeping an expensive player who’s not delivering on the pitch doesn’t make much sense for a club chasing titles and consistent results. If the relationship between Braithwaite and the club keeps souring, a move to MLS could be the best way out for everyone involved. Braithwaite finds a new home, Grêmio frees up some budget space, and maybe they bring in someone who can actually make a difference on the field.

The truth is, sticking with Grêmio means facing the heat, working hard to win back the fans, and, who knows, maybe turning things around. But a switch to MLS could mean less pressure, more peace of mind, and the chance to shine in a different setting. Braithwaite’s got the name, the experience, and, most importantly, the talent—even if that talent hasn’t quite shown itself at Grêmio just yet.

So, is Braithwaite gonna follow in the footsteps of so many other European stars and find his new beginning in MLS at the end of the season? Or will he double down in Brazil and try to prove he can still be the hero Grêmio desperately needs?

One thing’s for sure: wherever he ends up, Braithwaite’s gonna have to show a lot more than he has so far in Brazil if he wants to win back the respect and trust of fans, whether they’re in Brazil or the U.S.

If I were in his shoes, I’d say a move to MLS is looking more and more like a smart play. I mean, who wouldn’t wanna trade the relentless criticism in Porto Alegre for the “American dream”?