The Farewell Few Expected at St. Louis CITY SC

St. Louis CITY SC doesn't forgive slip-ups in 2024
FC Dallas v St Louis City SC
FC Dallas v St Louis City SC / Bill Barrett/ISI Photos/GettyImages

Monday dawned differently for St. Louis CITY SC fans. The news of coach Bradley Carnell's dismissal hit like a bombshell. Carnell, who not long ago was seen as the savior after a historic inaugural season in 2023, now exits amidst bitter defeat in 2024. The coach who led St. Louis to the top of the Western Conference last year now bids farewell with a bitter taste of loss.

No one said it would be easy, and indeed it wasn't. Carnell arrived at St. Louis with the mission to transform a debutant team into an MLS giant. And he succeeded, at least initially. In 2023, the team broke records and won hearts, finishing the regular season with 56 points and first place in the conference. But as they say, 'what goes up must come down,' and the descent was swift and painful.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

In 2024, St. Louis CITY SC found itself in a spiral of defeats and draws, culminating in a painful nine-game winless streak. The final straw came with the defeat to the Vancouver Whitecaps, squandering a two-goal lead to succumb 4-3. This string of poor results prompted the board to make drastic changes. Sporting Director Lutz Pfannenstiel made it clear that the decision to dismiss Carnell wasn't taken lightly but was necessary to salvage the season.

Carnell's departure raises a host of questions and uncertainties. After all, how can a coach who achieved so much in such a short time have his tenure abruptly halted? Results are everything, and when they don't materialize, the pressure becomes unsustainable. Carnell, with a record of 20 wins, 10 losses, and 15 draws in the league, couldn't maintain the required level of performance to secure his job.

John Hackworth, the new interim coach, faces the challenge of reversing this negative trend. With extensive experience in MLS and US national teams, Hackworth steps in with the daunting task of revitalizing a team that seems to have lost its identity. The challenge is immense but not insurmountable.

The future of St. Louis CITY SC is uncertain, but the board isn't sitting idle. Changes to the roster are expected with the opening of the transfer window on July 18th. Hackworth faces his first litmus test on July 3rd when St. Louis takes on the San Jose Earthquakes. It's a crucial match, not only for the standings but for team morale.

The decision to dismiss Carnell also reflects a philosophy of not settling for mediocrity. Pfannenstiel and club president Diego Gigliani emphasized that St. Louis's identity and playing philosophy won't change. The team will continue to pursue a high-intensity, high-pressure style of play, characteristics that defined its meteoric rise in 2023.