The Brazilian soccer world was taken aback by Cuiabá's acquisition of Max Alves, a player at the center of an international investigation into match-fixing. While the Brazilian Superior Court of Sports Justice (STJD) has not imposed any punishment on the player, moral and ethical concerns loom over the club's decision to include him in their roster for the 2024 season.
The lingering question is: is it okay for Cuiabá to have Max Alves on board simply because he hasn't been judged by the STJD? Legality often falls short in determining what is right or wrong in a broader context.
The Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) sought to extend national sanctions to the international level, a move that could have impacted players like Max, but surprisingly, the Brazilian player sidestepped this setback. The argument that he wasn't playing in Brazil when suspended by the MLS raises another question: should geographical borders determine the extent of a player's ethical responsibility?
Even though Max Alves has not been formally investigated by the Public Ministry of Goiás, the presence of his name in suspicious financial transactions casts shadows over his integrity. Soccer, aside from being a sporting spectacle, is an influential platform in society, where athletes are viewed as role models and influencers. Maintaining ethical standards is crucial to preserving the integrity of the sport.
Max Alves's case is not isolated. Other players have faced similar situations, with some being suspended from their clubs and others reaching agreements for reduced penalties. The inconsistency in decisions highlights the need for a deeper reflection on the ethical criteria adopted by clubs and the sports system itself.
Cuiabá's signing of Max Alves not only questions the player's integrity but also the ethical stance of the club. The pursuit of victories and titles cannot, under any circumstances, compromise the fundamental values that govern both sports and society. Brazilian soccer now faces a crucial challenge: balancing the desire for sporting success with the preservation of ethical principles that uphold the true spirit of the game.