St. Louis Lets Victory Slip in the Final Minutes

“Did someone forget to tell the defenders the game had started?” Yeah, that’s exactly how I felt watching the wild, yet confusing, 4-4 draw between St. Louis CITY SC and Portland Timbers. Seriously, who would’ve predicted a goalfest like that?

Providence Park in Portland was the stage for one of those classic matches where every minute counts. St. Louis CITY SC came out swinging, pushing the pace right from the first whistle. By the 11th minute, Simon Becher had already found the back of the net with a header that’s definitely worth a replay. Then came a stone-cold penalty from Eduard Löwen, putting them up 2-0. At that point, any St. Louis fan was probably grinning ear to ear, beer in hand, thinking the game was in the bag. But, of course, soccer is never that simple, and the tide turned fast.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Jonathan Rodríguez cut the lead in half at the 39th minute with a well-timed strike, and just as the first half was about to close, Cedric Teuchert seemed to bury any hope the Timbers had with another goal for St. Louis. 3-1 at halftime? Easy street, right? All they had to do was control the game in the second half, lock down the defense, and history would write itself. But, nope, that’s not how it played out.

St. Louis’ defense, which might as well have stayed in the locker room, came back onto the field moving slower than a snail on a lazy afternoon. And honestly, this isn’t the first time it’s happened. Felipe Mora capitalized on the defensive chaos, scoring twice, and Evander—who, by the way, hadn’t been making much noise until then—delivered a killer free kick in stoppage time to tie the game. Can you blame goalkeeper Roman Bürki? Not really. He’d been trying to put out defensive fires all night long.

So, how does St. Louis manage to score four goals but still let three points slip away so frustratingly? If you’re watching from the sidelines, it might seem like the team has an incredible offensive force, and yeah, they do. Marcel Hartel, with three assists in this game alone, has burst onto the scene like a wrecking ball. But when your attack works its tail off to give you a three-goal cushion, and your defense lets it all drain away, somebody’s got some explaining to do.

It’s easy to sit here and say the team needs to tighten up defensively. That’s obvious. But the truth is, the problem seems deeper than just tactical adjustments. St. Louis CITY SC is struggling with a lack of focus and a drop in intensity during the crucial moments of the game. It’s like they switch off right when it matters most, letting teams exploit these weaknesses with ease.

As for Portland, they’re not exactly walking away from this one with a ton of praise either, despite the heroic comeback. Sure, Felipe Mora showed he’s got that nose for goal, and Evander stepped up when they needed him most. But a team that gives up three goals in the first half at home has just as much, if not more, to work on than St. Louis.

What’s clear here is that we’re watching two teams with incredible potential, but so far, they’re showing signs of inconsistency and immaturity. On one side, you’ve got St. Louis, capable of steamrolling anyone with their sharp front line. On the other, there’s Portland, who, despite not shining in attack for most of the match, managed to stay alive and snatch a draw in stoppage time.

St. Louis CITY SC, with guys like Becher, Hartel, and Teuchert, has one of the most exciting attacks to watch. But if they keep letting opponents claw their way back into games like this, the season could end up fizzling out without much to show for it.

From here on out, St. Louis’ coach needs to hammer home that it’s not enough to be fast and efficient up front. Championships are won with solid defense. Roman Bürki, the goalkeeper, can’t be expected to be the last line of defense game after game. He did his part with seven key saves, but at the end of the day, you can’t expect him to stop every bomb that comes his way when the defense is full of holes.

“But they’re not playing badly, right? Four goals away from home isn’t something you see every day.” And I totally agree. It’s not something you see every day. But the problem isn’t what they’re doing right; it’s what they’re ignoring. And what they’re ignoring is that a shaky defense can undo any hard work the attack puts in. What’s the point of having heavy artillery up front if, on the other side, there’s a wide-open gate letting in goals like nobody’s guarding it?

Will St. Louis keep being this emotional rollercoaster for their fans, or will they figure out a way to balance things out? As long as the attack keeps striking fear into any defense in the league, the key will be shoring up the back line. If they can do that, then we might start talking about them as serious contenders for more than just exciting nights.