Shaqiri: The Hype That Just Didn’t Pay Off

Xherdan Shaqiri, the Swiss star who arrived at the Chicago Fire with all the hype and big promises, ended up leaving in, let’s say, a pretty frustrating way. His journey in American soccer started with a huge contract, but wrapped up two years earlier than expected with a so-called "mutual" separation.

Back in February 2022, it seemed like the Chicago Fire had hit a home run by signing Shaqiri as their new "Designated Player." Now, if you’re not up to speed with MLS lingo, that’s the player teams can pay more for—above the salary cap. Basically, teams bet big on these guys, expecting them to work some magic on the field. And let’s be real, when you fork out €6.5 million (or about $7.5 million) for a player—the priciest signing in the club's history—you expect them to, well, make it rain.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

And honestly, who could blame the Fire for taking that gamble? Shaqiri had a resume to back it up. I mean, this guy played for European giants like Bayern Munich and Liverpool, not to mention his stellar moments with the Swiss national team. It wasn’t hard to picture him tearing up MLS defenses and leading Chicago back to the glory days. But, as we all know, things didn’t quite follow the script. So, what went wrong?

Sometimes what looks perfect on paper just doesn’t translate into real life. The union between Shaqiri and the Chicago Fire felt like one of those relationships that, despite all the promises, just never clicked. Right from the start, it seemed like the Swiss midfielder wasn’t quite in tune with the MLS rhythm. Sure, he had his flashes of brilliance, but he never became that game-changing leader the club desperately needed.

If you take a step back and look at the whole picture, it becomes clear that Shaqiri’s arrival came with almost unrealistic expectations. The Fire bet everything on a player who, honestly, may have already peaked. Yeah, Shaqiri’s still talented, no doubt about that, but he’s not the same guy who wowed us at Bayern Munich or Liverpool. And let’s not kid ourselves—MLS is no second-rate league. Nowadays, it’s way more competitive, and the stars coming in from overseas need to be ready to give it their all, 110%, every single game.

Then there’s the whole adjustment thing. MLS is a different beast. The travel distances are insane, the playing style is its own animal, and the schedule? It’s kind of bonkers, to be honest. Shaqiri might have tons of experience in Europe, but playing in North America is a different challenge altogether, physically and mentally. Did he underestimate that? Maybe. Maybe he didn’t fully adapt to the new way of life, or maybe the injuries took a bigger toll than anyone expected.

Another thing we can’t ignore is Shaqiri’s connection—or lack thereof—with the club and his surroundings. The Swiss star came in with all the fanfare, but it felt like he never truly got comfortable at Chicago Fire. Maybe the fit with the coach wasn’t quite right, or maybe the team’s mindset didn’t sync up with his. Whatever the reason, something was off. The guy who was supposed to be the maestro of the team ended up being just another cog in a machine that wasn’t running smoothly to begin with.

On August 14, 2024, Shaqiri and the Chicago Fire announced they were parting ways—"mutually." Now, let’s be real, those mutual splits always feel like one of those breakups where both sides claim they’re still friends, but deep down, everyone’s just relieved to be out of the mess. Shaqiri said it was the "right time" to explore new opportunities, but in reality, both he and the club were probably just sick of each other. It’s like being in a relationship that’s going nowhere, and instead of dragging it out, you just call it quits before things get ugly.

In the end, Chicago Fire and Shaqiri walked away, hand in hand, but heading in different directions. Maybe, just maybe, this breakup is for the best. But one thing’s for sure—this whole saga is a wake-up call for any MLS team thinking that signing a European star will magically fix all their problems. Because at the end of the day, soccer’s about more than just big names.