Rebuild or Crisis? How Will the Union Survive Without Its Stars?

When the transfer window slams shut, there's often that bitter aftertaste for fans. And for Philadelphia Union supporters, that bitterness has a name: Julián Carranza and José Martínez. It feels like something solid, something unshakeable, might be crumbling. But is the Union on the verge of collapse, or can the club pull off a reinvention?

Carranza was a rare gem, a player who clicked perfectly in the Union's attack. His move to Feyenoord left a massive hole. Those lightning runs, his finishing touch, and even his physical presence on the field were like a finely-tuned symphony driving the Union's offense. Now, with him on the other side of the Atlantic, the million-dollar question is: who's gonna fill that void?

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

And so, the Union bets on Sam Adeniran, a player coming over from St. Louis City. Let’s be real here—it’s not the kind of signing that gets fans jumping out of their seats or rushing to buy jerseys. Adeniran is like that spare tire you keep in your car because your main one blew out halfway down the road. Functional? Sure. But exciting? Not so much. Still, you can’t deny Adeniran’s got some talent, and he might be able to cover for Carranza in the short run. But does he have what it takes to become the Union’s next big thing, or is he just a temporary fix?

If Carranza was the engine that stopped running, José Martínez was the brakes that kept the team balanced. "El Brujo," as the fans lovingly called him, was crucial in protecting the defense and transitioning through midfield. But let’s face it, the last 18 months haven’t been kind to him. His form dipped, and maybe it was time for a change of scenery. His move to Corinthians makes sense for both the player and the club. But for the Union, his departure feels like yanking the emergency brake while speeding downhill.

Yet, it’s not time to hit the panic button—not just yet. The Union has already made moves, bringing in Danley Jean Jacques, a wild card who could surprise everyone. He’s being seen as a direct replacement for Martínez, but let’s not kid ourselves: replacing a player who knew the team inside and out isn’t a walk in the park. Jean Jacques steps into massive shoes, and the pressure is gonna be sky-high.

And what about Richard Odada’s exit to Dundee United? Okay, maybe not the biggest name, but he was valuable to the squad. Sometimes, it’s those unsung players who end up being missed the most when you’re patching up the roster. Odada was one of those guys who quietly did the dirty work, and when you tally up the losses, his absence will sting too.

At the same time, the Union is betting on a homegrown solution by promoting CJ Olney, a rising star from their academy. It’s always great to see a club putting faith in its own talent. But let’s be honest: pinning hopes on a young academy player is like betting it all on a green horse. The reward could be huge, but the disappointment could be quick. Olney’s got potential, no doubt, but can he handle the weight of being the Union's homegrown hope?

The exits of Carranza and Martínez left the team feeling stripped of its identity. And the new arrivals are, well, question marks. Sam Adeniran, Danley Jean Jacques, and CJ Olney are good bets, but they're not guarantees. To be fair, the Union made sensible choices with what they had. Losing Carranza and Martínez wasn’t management’s fault—it’s part of the market and the natural evolution of the game. But there’s no denying that the fans will need patience. The adaptation process for these new pieces won’t be instant, and until they start to deliver, there will be a cloud of uncertainty hanging over the Union.