Portland Timbers Plays It Safe, Misses Shot at Dominating MLS

The Portland Timbers entered this summer's transfer window like that team that has all the pieces in place but is still missing that cherry on top, you know? They had a well-rounded roster, no glaring gaps, which is rare in a league where teams tend to shop around like it’s the end of the month at the grocery store. They were sitting pretty, no need for a panic buy. Yet, they decided to bring in Mason Toye and Finn Surman, two players who add a bit of depth without shaking up the starting lineup. At first glance, it seemed like a calculated move, almost surgically planned to keep the squad’s balance intact.

But let’s be real—this caution feels kinda... lukewarm, doesn’t it? It’s that classic case of sticking to what works instead of going for even bigger gains.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

The buzzword here was "prudence." Sure, prudence is respectable, but it can also be a stand-in for a lack of daring. And when you're playing out West in the MLS, playing it safe can leave you lagging behind teams with a bit more hunger for glory.

What makes the Timbers' window fascinating is the opportunity they let slip through their fingers. Portland had everything set to become one of the heavyweights in the conference. They could’ve used the league rules to buy out Felipe Mora's contract, opening up a designated player spot. With that DP slot free, they could've brought in an elite striker, someone who’d send chills down the spine of every defender in the league. But instead, they chose the safer route.

Fans know the team could’ve taken a bigger leap. That’s not to say Mason Toye and Finn Surman won’t bring value to the squad. Far from it—they’re versatile players and provide solid cover for injuries or suspensions. Toye, for example, could be that immediate sub every coach loves to have ready, capable of changing the game's flow. Surman, on the other hand, is young and promising, but he's not arriving with that untouchable starter status.

Now, imagine if they’d dared a bit more. What if, instead of bringing in players to “fill out the roster,” they’d gone after a star? Someone who could lead the attack, carry the team on their back, and turn the Timbers into undeniable title contenders?

Transfers—or the lack of them—often tell a bigger story than just buying and selling players. Take Dairon Asprilla, for example. He left to join Atlético Nacional. Asprilla wasn’t a global star, but he had a deep connection with the club and the fans. His departure, while not earth-shattering, signals a shift in the guard. Maybe the Timbers felt it was time to refresh, to turn the page. Yet, the exit of Larrys Mabiala, with his contract running out, and the mutual termination of Nathan Fogaça’s deal, also point to a small transformation at the club, though nothing too radical.

Still, it’s hard not to feel like this transformation could’ve been bigger, bolder, more daring. But the Timbers' front office chose the cautious route. And who can blame them? The Timbers have potential, no doubt. They've got a solid squad, talented players, and a system that works.