Orlando City Shines but Crumbles in Penalty Shootout at Leagues Cup

Winning isn't always enough. And Orlando City felt that sting in one of those nights when, no matter how hard you try, the ball just won’t find the back of the net. Up against Cruz Azul, one of Mexico's giants, Oscar Pareja's squad showed they’re on the right track, but the harsh lottery of penalties decided that the magical night would be remembered for the pain of elimination.

Oscar Pareja made it clear how much the team gave. This wasn’t just another game. Facing Cruz Azul is no easy feat, and Orlando City proved they’re not here to mess around. From the first whistle, the Mexicans came out swinging, full intensity, sharp technique, and a strategy that bordered on perfection. But the Lions from Florida weren’t intimidated. Far from it—they fought back, heads held high, taking on the challenge toe-to-toe.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Pareja and his men knew the chances would be few and had to be taken with surgical precision. Unfortunately, the ball just wouldn't cooperate. They created the best opportunities, sure, but that final touch, the one that turns plays into goals, was missing. So, at the end of the 90 minutes, the scoreboard showed a 0-0 that didn’t reflect the game. It felt like fate was setting up an extra test for Orlando City: the penalty shootout.

Ah, penalties... Always treacherous, they’re like an unforgiving judge, deciding in seconds what 90 minutes couldn't settle. And this time, fate wasn’t smiling on Pareja’s players. One after another, the takers tried, but luck was elsewhere. Cruz Azul came out on top, and Orlando, even without losing on the pitch, saw their Leagues Cup dream slip away.

However, what remains isn’t just the pain of elimination. There’s the sense that this team, this group, is maturing, finding its rhythm and identity. As Robin Jansson rightly pointed out, the team played well, controlled the game, and defended with mastery. There were few dangerous moments from the Mexican side, and when they did arise, Pedro Gallese was there to make sure Cruz Azul didn’t take the lead.

The defensive performance, which has been a standout in recent matches, was once again exemplary. Not conceding against a team like Cruz Azul is no small feat. And despite the frustration of not advancing, there’s plenty to be proud of. The team showed they’re solid, focused, and that’s crucial for the rest of the season.

What this game clearly shows is that Orlando City is ready to face whatever comes their way in the MLS. The Leagues Cup might be over, but the lessons learned are invaluable.