Lothar Matthäus and His Controversial MLS Farewell

When you think of Lothar Matthäus, you picture greatness—titles, dominance, a career that touched the biggest stages of soccer. From the Bundesliga to the World Cup, this guy was unstoppable. But like every story, there are chapters that make you scratch your head. One of the most puzzling? His final stint in the United States, playing for the MetroStars in Major League Soccer (MLS).

Matthäus ended his playing days with a dash of controversy and, honestly, a bit of an anticlimactic finale. Let’s face it: when he left Bayern Munich to head to the U.S., it felt more like a retirement vacation than a strategic career move. Back in 2000, MLS was still finding its feet. It didn’t have the glitz or the respect it enjoys today.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

The year was 2000, and Matthäus had the chance to be the star MLS desperately needed. But instead of staying focused on healing a back injury, guess what? He made a pit stop in St. Tropez. Yeah, you heard right. Rather than being in a rehab center, he was soaking up the sun on the French Riviera.

So, what do we do with this legacy? On the one hand, you can't deny Matthäus's greatness. The guy's a World Cup winner, a Bayern legend, and easily one of the all-time greats. But his time in MLS? Well, let’s just say it was a little... messy.

When he signed with the MetroStars, it seemed like a perfect match. MLS needed big names to grab attention and fill stadiums. And Matthäus? He needed a final chapter before hanging up his boots. But there was a problem. It became clear that he wasn’t as committed as you'd expect from someone of his caliber. He played from March to October of 2000, but “memorable” isn’t exactly how you'd describe his performance. If the goal was to raise the bar for MLS, well, maybe he didn’t quite hit that mark.

Now, before anyone accuses me of being unfair, let’s be real. Soccer in the U.S. wasn’t what it is today. MLS didn’t have the infrastructure we see now. Back then, playing in the States was almost like a vacation for European veterans. And to be honest, Matthäus wasn’t the only big name to treat the U.S. as a pre-retirement pit stop. We’ve seen this story play out with plenty of other famous players. But while Beckham brought some serious glamour and a work ethic that couldn’t be denied, Matthäus seemed to treat it all like a farewell tour with little investment.

Here’s where the irony kicks in. Even with such a dazzling career, Matthäus leaves us with these nagging questions: Did he ever really take MLS seriously? Or was it just a career footnote, a way to grab a few headlines before calling it quits?

Let’s not forget, he was part of the MetroStars squad that won the MLS Eastern Division title in 2000. Yeah, Matthäus was there for that. But let’s be honest, it’s not exactly the kind of trophy he’d highlight on his resume. It’s not the Champions League, it’s not the World Cup. And for someone who always seemed driven by excellence, winning the MLS Eastern Division doesn’t seem like it was part of the grand plan.

Now, about that St. Tropez trip—come on, seriously? If you’re a pro athlete in the middle of a season, and your body’s telling you it needs some care, the last place you should be is lounging on a luxury beach. That’s like a CEO taking a vacation in the middle of a corporate meltdown. Sure, everyone needs a break, but timing is everything. Matthäus’s choice to jet off to the French coast was bad, plain and simple. It looked terrible for him and the team. It left everyone with the feeling that he wasn’t really in it for the long haul.

But can we really judge him that harshly? He was at the tail end of his career and had already won everything there was to win. Maybe, for him, this was just a way to enjoy the last stretch of his professional life. Maybe he viewed MLS as a secondary gig, a final act that didn’t hold much significance. Or maybe he was just tired—physically and mentally—after years of playing at the highest level. Who are we to judge?

What’s funny is that despite this messy ending, Matthäus remains a legend. His reputation in Europe and around the world wasn’t really tarnished by his time in the U.S. But let’s be real: this chapter of his career will always come with an asterisk. One of the greatest players ever stumbled a bit at the end of the road.

The takeaway from this whole saga is a mix of admiration and frustration. Admiration for the player he was and all the glory he achieved. But frustration because it feels like he didn’t give MLS his best, like he could’ve gone out with a little more shine, a little more dignity.

So, was Matthäus a hero or a villain in this story? Maybe he was a bit of both. A hero who was simply worn out, but who, in the end, still left his mark—even if it’s a little smudged—on American soccer.