LAFC Backs Out of Selling Cristian Olivera to Toluca

Look, it’s not unusual for a deal to fall through in the final moments. But when it happens, like with Cristian Olivera and LAFC, it hits hard—like a last-minute goal that flips the game on its head. Let's be real, no one saw Toluca getting left out in the cold, but that’s exactly what went down.

Toluca, the Liga MX squad, had everything lined up to bring the 22-year-old Uruguayan, Cristian Olivera, on board. They slapped $8 million on the table, just waiting for the ink to dry on the contract. But, in a plot twist straight out of a Hollywood thriller, LAFC decided to pull the rug out from under the Mexicans and keep the player in Los Angeles.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

So, why would a club, staring down a sweet deal like that, back out at the eleventh hour? The answer’s pretty straightforward and makes total sense: LAFC didn’t have a replacement for Olivera. You can’t just sell a top player—you’ve gotta have a plan B, someone who can step into those big shoes.

And timing was everything here. The transfer window’s about to slam shut, and LAFC realized that selling Olivera would leave a gaping hole on the left wing, one that could cost them big time this season. The pressure to keep a competitive squad is massive, and the folks running the show know that losing a key player without a quick replacement could be like shooting themselves in the foot. And it seems no one was willing to pull that trigger.

Cristian Olivera isn’t just any player. He’s the kind of young talent that makes scouts drool. With his dribbling skills, lightning speed, and a knack for finding the back of the net, he’s not the type you just stumble upon. In a cutthroat market like Major League Soccer (MLS), where talent is getting harder and harder to come by, losing a guy like that would’ve been a strategic blunder, to say the least.

Now, on Toluca’s side, it’s a whole different story. You can almost feel the frustration from the Mexican club and their fans as they watch a major signing slip through their fingers. They were banking on Olivera to bring not just technical skills, but also a certain star power—a presence that could’ve boosted the team’s profile in Liga MX. Toluca’s no pushover, but they needed that extra punch to stand out even more. Missing out on this deal is bound to leave a sour taste.

That said, LAFC’s move can be seen in two ways. To some, the American club played it smart, putting the team’s interests above any amount of cash. To others, it was a risky call, as turning down that offer meant passing up a golden opportunity to strengthen the finances and maybe bring in some fresh talent.

But let’s be honest, money matters, but it’s not everything in soccer. If it were, PSG would be winning the Champions League every year. What really counts is having a tight-knit team, with players who click on the field and can deliver results. And it looks like LAFC chose to keep their Uruguayan gem, betting that he could be the key to achieving something bigger this season.

The player, who was all but packed and ready to head to Mexico, must’ve been thrown for a loop by this turn of events. Now, he knows he’s crucial to the team—that the front office believes in him so much they’d cancel a multi-million dollar deal. This could boost his confidence and push him to play even better. Or, of course, it could have the opposite effect, leaving him feeling like he just missed out on a huge opportunity.