As the sun dipped below the horizon over Cincinnati on that fateful Friday, few could have predicted the storm brewing on the TQL Stadium pitch. FC Cincinnati, once the underestimated "ugly duckling" of Major League Soccer, was up against the seasoned Santos Laguna in the 2024 Leagues Cup.
The whistle had barely blown, and before fans could even settle in, a defensive blunder made it clear that this could be a nightmarish evening. Just five minutes in, debutant Chidozie Awaziem, more jittery than a cat on moving day, failed to control the ball inside his own box. A fatal mistake that Santos Laguna's Antony Lozano seized upon with the precision of a surgeon, slotting the ball into the back of the net. The stadium, vibrant moments before, fell silent as if time had momentarily stopped.
Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).
But FC Cincinnati wasn’t about to bow down to Mexican tradition. Just six minutes later, Luca Orellano, with the audacity of the greats, decided this game would take a different turn. With a touch of magic, he dribbled past the defender, regained possession, and unleashed a curving shot from outside the box, straight into the top corner. The ball seemed guided by a greater destiny, leaving the Santos Laguna keeper frozen, almost like a statue. The TQL Stadium erupted in cheers and applause, transforming the equalizer into a resurrection.
Despite their dominance, the winning goal never came during the 90 minutes. Frustrated attempts, like Yuya Kubo's missed penalty, seemed to foreshadow an impending tragedy. However, the team remained steadfast, controlling the game with an almost eerie calmness, as if they knew the outcome was already written. It was a match that tested not only skill but the psyche of every player. And amidst numerous attacks, Santos Laguna doubled down on aggression. With the referee hesitant to use his cards, the game took on the feel of a battlefield. The atmosphere heated up, and the tension between players culminated in a confrontation at the end of the first half, with opposing keeper Carlos Acevedo squaring off with Miles Robinson.
The second half brought the nerves of an impending decision. Coach Pat Noonan, aware that the game called for a touch of brilliance, played his ace: Luciano Acosta. The Argentine, the star of the 2023 MLS season, had been sidelined due to injury, but on this night, the team needed his spark more than ever. With Acosta on the field, Cincinnati gained the confidence that they could finish the game in regulation time. But the winning goal remained elusive, and fate pushed the match into penalties.
Penalty shootouts are, by definition, an emotional roulette. Each player steps up to the spot like a gunslinger in an Old West duel, where any slip can be fatal. But that night, Cincinnati's men were possessed by an almost superhuman calm. One by one, they converted their shots with the precision of surgeons: Acosta, Kelsy, Orellano, Baird, Bucha, and finally, Sergio Santos. Each strike was a blow to Santos Laguna's morale. On the other side, the Mexicans held firm until Aldo López, under the suffocating pressure of the atmosphere, sent the ball soaring into the distance.
Moving on to the Round of 16, FC Cincinnati already has a new challenge in mind: Philadelphia Union. Pat Noonan's team will have the chance to play in front of their home crowd once again, and with confidence soaring, there's already talk of a title. But caution is key.