How Did MLS Let Manchester United's Facundo Pellistri Slip Away for Just €6 Million?

Facundo Pellistri has been on the radar of top clubs for a while now, but it seems like his time with Manchester United has come to an end. His move to Panathinaikos, sealed for a shockingly low €6 million, has left many stunned. And I’m not just talking about the price tag, but the fact that Major League Soccer clubs like San Jose Earthquakes, Charlotte FC, Houston Dynamo, and Chicago Fire sat back and watched it all unfold without lifting a finger. It’s the kind of opportunity that knocks loud and clear, but apparently, MLS clubs prefer to sleep through it.

Let’s be real here. MLS has already proven to be a hotbed for young talent, especially from Latin America. The league’s growing, it’s modernizing, but it still struggles to recognize the gems right under its nose. Pellistri is a prime example of this blindness. The young kid’s got sky-high potential, and anyone keeping up with Uruguayan soccer knows he’s got what it takes to surpass any of his compatriots shining in MLS today.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

How does a player with that kind of skill, with that energy, who could’ve easily injected new life into any MLS team, end up in Greece, in a deal that feels more like a flea market steal than a high-level transfer? It’s a textbook case of a missed opportunity. And while MLS snoozes on this chance, Panathinaikos is grinning from ear to ear, thrilled to snag Pellistri for a bargain.

Don’t get me wrong, Panathinaikos isn’t just some random club. The Greek giants have history, they’ve got a solid fanbase, and now, they’ve got Pellistri. But what really stands out in this deal is the role that Uruguayan coach Diego Alonso played in the young player’s decision. The coach, known for his fearless style and firm grip, was the "X-factor" that made the deal happen.

It’s almost ironic to think that Manchester United, such a massive club, agreed to let Pellistri go for what, to them, is pocket change. The English side seems to have made peace with what could be a future loss, of course covering themselves with a sell-on clause. Don’t be fooled, the Red Devils know Pellistri could still break out, but they chose to let him leave instead of waiting to see if his potential would fully blossom at Old Trafford.

Meanwhile, MLS is sleeping at the wheel. The clubs mentioned earlier had every opportunity to get in on the race for Pellistri. But they just stood there, arms crossed, maybe waiting for another big name to fall into their laps. What a blown chance! It wouldn’t be the first time the American league missed out on a smart move, but this mistake might cost them down the road. Imagine what Pellistri could’ve done in any of those clubs. Instead, he’ll be lighting up Greek stadiums while MLS fans are left asking themselves, “What if?”

If there’s one thing we’ve learned from this deal, it’s that opportunities don’t last forever. And with Pellistri, this was an opportunity that slipped right through MLS’s fingers like sand. He’s like a star that’s still forming but is sure to shine bright sooner or later.

And what about Panathinaikos? Well, they’re laughing all the way to the bank. They got themselves a player who still has plenty to show, at a price that’s absurdly low. More than that, they’ve secured a player with a coach who speaks the same language, not just literally, but soccer-wise too. Diego Alonso knows what he’s doing, and Pellistri must trust that his future’s in good hands. Now, for those following MLS, it’s time to reflect. The league wants to grow, it wants to cement itself on the world stage, but how’s it gonna do that if it keeps ignoring talent of this caliber? MLS needs to stop only looking at veteran, established players and start investing in young prospects with the power to change the game. Sure, it’s great seeing big stars like Messi, but it’s also vital for the league’s future that young talents like Pellistri find a space to thrive within it.