Goodbye! Shaqiri Was a Letdown at Chicago Fire

When Xherdan Shaqiri landed in Chicago in early 2022, Fire fans saw a glimmer of hope at the end of the tunnel. It was as if, out of nowhere, the club had hit the jackpot, reeling in an international star with a résumé boasting stints at European giants like Bayern Munich, Inter Milan, and Liverpool. It's not every day a Major League Soccer (MLS) team manages to snag a player of this caliber, let alone one who was signed as a Designated Player—the cherry on top, the engine of the team.

But, folks, what happened between paper and pitch was a complete mismatch. Shaqiri, who arrived with the promise of making history, ended up becoming yet another sad chapter in the recent chronicles of Chicago Fire, a team that seems destined to wander in the MLS wilderness. His exit, now official, feels like a mutual sigh of relief, one of those breakups where both sides know it's best to move on, but nobody wants to admit the spark never truly caught fire.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Over his 75 appearances for Chicago, Shaqiri scored 16 goals and provided 13 assists. At first glance, the numbers don’t seem too shabby, but stats can be deceiving. For a player signed for a king's ransom, with a Hollywood-star salary, the impact was, at best, lukewarm. Let’s be honest, a lot more was expected from the Swiss international, who had shown flashes of brilliance throughout his European career—like that stunning goal in the Euros that’s still worth a replay today.

The problem is, in MLS, where tactics and physicality are valued more than refined technique, Shaqiri never quite found his footing. He was like a fish out of water, a conductor without an orchestra, a genius stranded in a team that, let’s face it, has never been known for its collective brilliance. Shaqiri, at 32 years old and with a history of injuries, always seemed a step behind, as if his mind was still playing in Europe’s grand arenas while his body struggled to keep up with the pace at Soldier Field.

There's an off-field factor that’s crucial in analyzing Shaqiri’s failure in Chicago: the club’s context. The Fire is a team that’s been trying to find itself for years. Since their last playoff appearance in 2017, they've been adrift, a ship lost at sea, searching for an identity that was never quite established. And Shaqiri, despite all his talent, couldn’t be the anchor or the captain to steer the Fire in a new, promising direction. His presence on the team was just another misplaced piece in a puzzle that never really fit together.

So, what happened? Reality came knocking. Shaqiri saw his performance decline year after year, his stats wither, and frustration set in. To make matters worse, the Fire, already on the brink of collapse, plummeted in the standings, ending the season in a dismal 14th place in the Eastern Conference. Then came the inevitable decision—a mutual agreement, a friendly parting of ways. No drama, no scandals, just an honest acknowledgment that it wasn’t working.

What does it really take for a player of Shaqiri’s caliber to shine in MLS? Clearly, it’s not enough to just have a big name or a glorious history in Europe. The league is a jungle of its own, with its own rules and a level of competitiveness that surprises even the most prepared. Players like Zlatan Ibrahimović and David Villa managed to adapt and thrive because they understood that in MLS, you need more than just skill with the ball.

In Shaqiri’s case, maybe it was that total commitment that was missing. There’s no denying his refined technique, but at times, it seemed like he was playing from afar, as if he wasn’t fully present, as if his mind was still wandering the pitches of Anfield or Allianz Arena. For Fire fans, the feeling that lingers is one of frustration, a bitter sense of being sold a dream that promised much and delivered little.

Now, with his departure, the Fire faces yet another rebuilding period, and the outlook isn’t exactly bright. With the imminent exit of sporting director Georg Heitz, the question of who will be the next big name for the team remains. Hugo Cuypers, the Fire’s new DP, and Gastón Giménez will have to bear the responsibility of bringing the Fire back to relevance. But, honestly, without a radical change in the club’s structure, the future looks bleak.