Franco Ibarra Won’t Be Returning to Atlanta United and Will Keep Playing in Argentina

What's happening in Argentina with Franco Ibarra is playing out like a soap opera script. The midfielder, who joined Rosario Central on loan from Atlanta United, has sparked a lot of interest from the Argentine club to keep him around. Ibarra's been a key player this season, and it seems like the "Canallas" want him to stick around, even if it means coughing up a few million dollars.

Rosario Central's plan? Keep Ibarra no matter what. His loan ends at the year's end, but the Argentine side has a buy option of around 4 million dollars for 80% of his rights. So, are they really gonna open up the wallet and make that heavy investment, or will they try to extend the loan instead?

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Ibarra arrived at Rosario and quickly became a key part of coach Miguel Ángel Russo's system. He’s got that gritty style fans love, leaves it all on the field, and has a physical presence that commands respect. In no time, he earned the team's trust and became a fan favorite. No wonder Rosario Central's eager to do whatever it takes to keep him on board. And rumor has it, the club's already working behind the scenes to make that happen.

But what about Atlanta United? That’s where things get more intense. Ibarra came to Atlanta as a promising talent, but he couldn’t really shine in MLS like everyone hoped. Heading to Argentina was, in a way, a shot at finding his form again—and, boy, did it work. Now, with Rosario Central showing a ton of interest in keeping him, Atlanta’s facing a tough call: sell him, extend the loan, or push for his return to the States.

The big question is: Is Rosario Central really ready to shell out the 4 million bucks for a permanent deal? Let's be real here—it’s no small change. The Argentine market's been struggling financially, so putting up that kind of cash requires a lot of confidence in the return. But, of course, the club might play around with other options, like negotiating to lower the price or extending the loan a bit longer to buy some financial breathing room while they see how things play out.

Now, if Atlanta United puts its foot down and demands Ibarra's return, Rosario Central might end up stuck in a tight spot. It wouldn’t be the first time an Argentine club loses a key player just because they can’t afford it. Ibarra himself seems pretty happy in Rosario, and the club is ready to fight to keep him. The ideal scenario for Rosario Central would be extending the loan, securing another season with him, and maybe setting the stage for a permanent deal down the road.

Another crucial piece in this puzzle is how Atlanta United views the whole situation. On one hand, getting Ibarra back could strengthen their squad and give their coach more options. On the other, the cash from a potential sale could give the club's finances a nice boost. Plus, they’ve got to think about the player's own wishes. Ibarra seems to be loving his time at Rosario. Sure, Atlanta might want to keep him around, but what's the point if he’s unhappy, right?

What's clear is that Rosario Central’s willing to negotiate, extend, pay up—do whatever it takes to keep Ibarra in their squad. But, of course, that depends on a lot of factors, from Atlanta United's flexibility to Rosario’s own financial situation.