Charlotte FC Surprises in the Transfer Window, Even Without Stars Almirón and Stengs

Charlotte FC’s transfer window was one for the books, filled with dreams that never quite made it to reality. They almost snagged Calvin Stengs and Miguel Almirón, two stars who could've taken the team to new heights. But let’s be honest: "almost" doesn’t win games, and it sure doesn’t bring home championships. So, was it a failure? Far from it.

While the spotlight was on their failed attempts at landing these marquee signings, Charlotte FC was quietly working its magic behind the scenes. The club ended up having one of its best transfer windows in recent memory. And it’s not just me saying that; the club’s actions speak for themselves. Instead of crying over spilled milk, they rolled up their sleeves and strengthened the squad with some savvy moves.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

First off, some departures might’ve left fans scratching their heads, but it was all part of a carefully crafted plan. Enzo Copetti’s move to Rosario Central, if you take a closer look, seems like one of those “tough but necessary” decisions. Sure, Copetti had his moments of brilliance, but he just wasn’t fitting into Charlotte’s style anymore. And then there’s Scott Arfield, the seasoned veteran who left on a free transfer. His departure signals a clear shift at Charlotte, one towards a younger, hungrier generation ready to prove themselves. Meanwhile, Hamady Diop was loaned out to FK Čukarički, a smart move to give the youngster more playing time and room to grow.

Now, if those three exits raised eyebrows, the signings Charlotte FC made definitely put any doubts to rest. The return of Karol Świderski after a loan spell at Verona was a stroke of genius. Świderski, who had already shown he’s a force to be reckoned with upfront, is back with renewed confidence and ready to make an impact. What looked like just a simple loan deal now feels like a masterstroke. Tim Ream, the veteran defender, came in as a free agent and brought with him a wealth of experience that you just can’t put a price on. Ream isn’t just another player; he’s practically a general on the field, the kind of leader every coach dreams of having. When the chips are down, a guy like him is your rock. And, let’s be real, a solid defense is half the battle won. Then there’s the arrival of Biel, straight from Olympiacos, bringing a fresh breath of hope to Charlotte’s attack. We’re not talking about just any player. Biel is versatile, smart, and, most importantly, he knows how to win games. Expectations are sky-high for him, and rightfully so. His glory days at Olympiacos suggest he might just be the missing piece Charlotte needed to turn good plays into goals.

Charlotte FC entered this window with high hopes, dreaming of landing players like Stengs and Almirón—big names that would’ve had the fans jumping out of their seats. But when those targets fell through, the club could’ve easily panicked, which is par for the course in the crazy world of transfers. Instead, Charlotte showed they’ve got a long-term vision, something rare in the instant gratification world of the transfer market. They didn’t make waves with multi-million dollar deals, but they made smart moves, focusing on practical solutions that, in the long run, could pay off big time. They’ve bet on players who may not have the star power of an Almirón but have more than enough potential to shine.