Bento Estrela is The New Gem of Sporting Lisbon After Leaving New York Red Bulls

Bento Estrela, a young up-and-comer from the New York Red Bulls, is packing his bags and heading to Europe. At just 18, the kid who was once a beacon of hope for the future of MLS is now set to shine in Portugal, donning the Sporting jersey. But what does this move mean for the Red Bulls? And for Bento himself?

First off, Bento’s story is one of those rare early blooms. He stepped onto the professional scene just a day shy of 15, making him the fourth youngest player to sign in MLS history. The buzz around him was instant, like a storm on the horizon. But instead of thunder and lightning, Bento’s development was more like a cloudy day that never really broke into sunshine. That is, until now.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

He spent most of his time playing for New York Red Bulls II—a team that’s great for cutting your teeth but not exactly where you’d expect the next Messi to emerge. With 36 appearances and just one assist, Bento never really got his shot to prove himself with the Red Bulls’ first team. Did he truly get the chance he deserved? Or is the MLS system dropping the ball when it comes to nurturing young talent?

The Red Bulls, of course, are chasing their 15th consecutive playoff appearance, trying to keep their competitive edge in MLS. But this relentless pursuit of immediate success might be costing them in the long run. Players like Bento, who should be groomed for stardom, end up on the sidelines—no game time, no real chance to shine. Instead of fostering these young talents, the system often opts for seasoned players who can deliver quick results.

So, what happens next? They leave. And Bento Estrela is now en route to Lisbon, joining one of Portugal’s most storied clubs, Sporting. This is no small move. Sporting has a knack for turning young talents into global superstars. Just look at Cristiano Ronaldo, who started there before conquering the world. If there’s a place where Bento can finally realize his full potential, it’s at Sporting.

But let’s be real—Bento’s success at Sporting is no sure thing. Europe is a tough arena for young players. The pressure is intense, the competition is fierce. He’s going to face challenges he’s never encountered before—from grueling training sessions to the breakneck pace of the Primeira Liga. But this is also the golden opportunity he’s been waiting for. If he can make his mark at Sporting, Bento could not only achieve his dreams but also pave the way for other young MLS talents who feel stuck in a system that often seems too focused on the here and now, blind to the future.

But don’t get it twisted—losing a talent like Bento Estrela isn’t something to shrug off. It’s a wake-up call that something might be off in how young players are being managed in MLS. If the league truly wants to compete on the global stage, it needs to start paying more attention to its young players, making sure they get the game time and support they need to develop. Otherwise, Bento Estrela’s story will be just one of many, and MLS will keep being seen as a league that exports promises instead of producing stars.