Alexandre Pato's Frustrating Run at Orlando City

When Pato landed at Orlando City in February 2021, the buzz was real. Here we had a player who, early on in his career, was billed as one of the brightest stars in world soccer. Pato had made a name for himself at Milan, lighting up Europe and showing flashes of brilliance at various clubs. So when Orlando City started flooding their social media with duck emojis, people couldn’t help but get excited. And just like that, the Brazilian forward arrived in Major League Soccer (MLS) as a free agent, signing a one-year deal.

A guy with an international rep, tons of skill, and that signature Brazilian flair—sounds like a recipe for success, right? But, man, those injuries came knocking. In his very first game against Atlanta United, Pato tweaked his knee. And this wasn’t just a little sprain. By the 80th minute, Pato had to limp off, and you could almost feel the energy drain from Orlando City fans. Optimism quickly turned into this cloud of uncertainty.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

After that? It was all downhill. The knee injury turned out to be serious enough to need surgery. Pato went under the knife for arthroscopic knee surgery, and while he was sidelined, the 2021 season marched on without him. For a guy who arrived with high hopes, getting benched by an injury right out of the gate is the kind of thing that makes you scratch your head and wonder: "Was this worth it?"

Here’s the ironic twist—Pato, the former "wonderkid," just couldn’t shake this curse of unfulfilled potential. He didn’t make his comeback until October, six months after that rough debut. And when he did return, it was a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment. Subbed in at the 86th minute in a lackluster draw against CF Montréal. I mean, what can you really do with just a few minutes on the field?

Okay, so at least he’s back, right? Sure, but here’s the kicker. By the end of 2021, Pato had racked up just 116 minutes across five matches. Yep, the guy who was supposed to be Orlando City’s “big signing” spent more time warming the bench and rehabbing than actually playing.

Still, maybe out of hope or desperation, Orlando City re-upped his contract for another year in 2022. Maybe they thought, "Hey, with some more recovery time, he’ll finally hit his stride." After all, everyone knew Pato had talent. It was there, hiding just beneath the surface, but something always seemed to hold him back.

But here’s the thing—sometimes talent just isn’t enough. MLS is a fast-evolving league. The intensity and physical demands keep ramping up. And Pato, after so much time off and with an injury record that follows him like a shadow, just couldn’t keep up. By the time November 2022 rolled around, Orlando City made the call everyone had seen coming: they weren’t interested in extending his contract for 2023. A predictable end to a story that had way more frustration than highlights.

So, why was Pato’s time at Orlando such a letdown? Sure, the injuries were a huge factor. But let’s not ignore the fact that the game itself has changed. What worked a decade ago, when Pato burst onto the global scene, doesn’t necessarily fly today. That goes for both the physical and mental sides of the game. Soccer demands more than ever from players, and if you’re losing time to injuries or struggling to get into a rhythm, it can be a career killer.

It’s sad to see a player like Pato go through that, especially when you know how much raw talent he has. Sometimes, no matter how skilled you are, if your body doesn’t hold up or the circumstances aren’t right, you end up being another "what if" story.

Pato’s stint at Orlando City was like one of those bets you place, hoping for the best but always with that nagging doubt in the back of your mind. He came in with promises, but left leaving fans feeling like he never truly fit.