NYCFC Turns the Tables on Favorite Cincinnati and Keeps the Dream Alive

In a do-or-die atmosphere, NYCFC put on a show of resilience, dispatching FC Cincinnati in the second playoff match. It was one of those games where you could feel NYCFC playing like there was no tomorrow, because, for them, there really wasn't. Their 3-1 win at Citi Field didn’t just stave off an early exit.

The tension was thick from the get-go. Cincinnati came in as the favorite, thanks to a rock-solid season and recent winning streak against NYCFC. They seemed ready to punch their ticket to the next round. But the boys from New York had other plans. Fueled by a bold and fearless drive, they proved that it’s not just about being good, you’ve got to want it more. And NYCFC wanted it.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

The first half was all about the pressure, coming from both the crowd and the game itself. But NYCFC found a way to control the tempo and make their mark on the attack. Alonso Martínez broke the ice, and Thiago Martins doubled the lead at just the right moment, scoring a goal that energized the team and reassured everyone they were on the right track. Cincinnati tried to rally, with Luca Orellano nailing a sensational shot that revived the ghost of a comeback. But NYCFC didn’t flinch. Santiago Rodríguez sealed the deal in extra time, coolly slotting in a penalty like a seasoned pro.

This game tested more than just skill; it was a battle of endurance, played not only with their feet but with their hearts. And, of course, a good helping of strategy and discipline. For head coach Nick Cushing, the mission was clear: bend but don’t break. He knew they’d have to stay composed under pressure. And they did. With a rock-solid defense led by an inspired Thiago Martins and a practically unbeatable Matt Freese in goal, NYCFC stood their ground.

Speaking of Freese, he deserves his own shoutout. The guy was on fire, pulling off jaw-dropping saves. Especially in the 80th minute, when he stopped a game-tying shot with a breath-taking save that had the whole stadium holding its breath, then erupting in relief. It's wild he's not a finalist for best keeper of the season.

Now, NYCFC faces an even bigger challenge: winning at TQL Stadium, a place where they've lost three times just this season. Last time they were there, a 4-2 defeat in the Leagues Cup left a bitter taste of Cincinnati’s home-field firepower. But Cushing and his squad aren’t backing down. The coach believes there’s room to improve, especially in transitions and finishing. He knows that if they can fine-tune these areas, Cincinnati will have a much harder time.

There’s zero room for slip-ups. NYCFC knows the psychological edge is now on their side, with Cincinnati, once so sure, now facing big stakes on their home turf. And that could weigh heavy. Playing at home isn’t always a comfort; sometimes it’s a huge load. NYCFC plans to play on that. If they can keep their cool, absorb the pressure, and take advantage of every opening, they just might walk out of TQL Stadium with the win almost no one saw coming.