MLS Looks to Shift to a Fall-to-Spring Calendar

When it comes to growth, Major League Soccer doesn’t shy away from taking bold shots even if there’s a goalkeeper standing in the way. The latest conversation circling MLS HQ? Overhauling the league’s calendar, moving from the current spring-to-fall format to a fall-to-spring schedule, much like the European leagues. Decisions like this aren’t easy, but the goal here is clear: sync MLS with the global market, smooth out transfer operations, and, maybe just maybe, boost soccer’s visibility in the U.S.

This push to adopt an August-to-May season model isn’t random; it’s got a solid driver: the transfer windows. Right now, the summer transfer window, which runs on the global soccer schedule, slices straight through the middle of the MLS season. That situation leaves MLS teams in a real bind, caught in the crossfire of player transfers that often hit the league's competitiveness right where it hurts, especially as MLS has its sights set on pulling in more international talent.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Picture the impact of syncing up with the European calendar: U.S. clubs would finally get to negotiate their player deals without putting their season performance on the line. Club execs aren’t shy about voicing their wish for a transfer window that’s friendlier to MLS teams. Having a window that wraps up by September would be a dream; it’d let teams make strategic moves for those players left hanging after Europe’s high-stakes transfer battles. But until MLS adopts a Euro-aligned calendar, American clubs will keep hitting the crossbar in this market.

Besides the transfer window headaches, there’s also the question of the U.S. sports calendar. Right now, MLS finds itself squished between the NFL, NBA, MLB, and even college football. With so many American sports giants around, soccer often gets lost in the shuffle. Competing against the NFL playoffs or the NBA season opener is like trying to land a knockout punch with one hand tied. A shift to springtime finals in April or May would mean going head-to-head with lighter contenders like the NHL and NBA playoffs, while the NFL and MLB are still warming up.

The big winners of this August-to-May schedule would be the warmer markets, cities like Miami, Dallas, Houston, and Orlando, where even winter feels like a warm handshake. Meanwhile, fans up north in Toronto, Minnesota, and Chicago would be left braving icy winds and snowy stadiums. For them, swapping summer’s heat for a game-day freeze in November or February? That’s, at the very least, a risky kick. No one wants to see the stands empty just because the weather decided to remind fans that snow exists. So, MLS is diving into fan research, gauging the market, and trying to figure out if this schedule flip would actually please the crowd.

And like any big change, this one would shake up other tournaments, too, think Leagues Cup and the U.S. Open Cup. The Leagues Cup, which now takes over a month in the summer, would need to squeeze into a calendar with winter breaks and player rest periods. There’s talk of moving the Leagues Cup to January or February, which would create a fresh dynamic, with games taking place in warmer spots like California and Texas, dodging the north’s biting winter.

For those watching American soccer from the outside, this might seem like a simple adjustment, but it’s a lot more than that, it’s logistics, weather, and even public perception. Unlike in Europe, where soccer’s a century-old tradition, American fans are still building their passion for the game. Here in the U.S., soccer is still the sport of family weekends in the summer, and shifting that around messes with the sense of identity MLS has carefully built. Plus, a big slice of the MLS fanbase is made up of kids, and they’re off school in the summer.

There’s also the tricky balance of what MLS could gain in competitiveness and exposure. Aligning MLS with Europe’s calendar would indeed put the league on a more global track; yet, it might lose some of the unique appeal it’s carved out here at home. Amid the whirlwind of American sports, MLS has managed to craft its own story, its own prime time. So, is it worth giving that up for a more European schedule? Or should MLS focus on other ways to boost its strength and appeal?