FC Cincinnati and NYCFC Clash for Survival in the MLS Cup

Saturday’s showdown between FC Cincinnati and New York City FC is shaping up to be one for the books, no matter which way it swings. This decisive match in their best-of-three series will turn TQL Stadium into a stage for an all-out “do or die.” With each side holding one win, only one can advance to keep their MLS Cup title hopes alive.

In their first matchup, Cincinnati showed why they’ve been a force this season, clinching a 1-0 victory at home, a modest scoreline that belied their true dominance. With a staggering 22 shots to NYCFC’s mere six, Cincinnati’s performance was nothing short of commanding, bordering on a rout.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Yet NYCFC wasn’t about to play the supporting role. In the second game, the NYCFC squad looked reenergized, ready to leave it all on the field. They stormed back at Citi Field, winning 3-1 and breathing new life into the series. Heroes of the night included Alonso Martínez, Thiago Martins, and Santi Rodríguez, with the fans watching as if each goal lit another spark of hope. And the moment of brilliance? NYCFC’s goalie, Matt Freese, who delivered four jaw-dropping saves, practically holding the line single-handedly and elevating his team when they needed him most.

With one win apiece, the weight of this series now rests on the upcoming clash at TQL Stadium. Cincinnati, no stranger to holding the line at home, has been unbeatable on their turf all season, taking NYCFC down three times there with a clean 3-0 record at the Orange & Blue’s house.

For NYCFC, however, a renewed sense of hope arrives with the return of defender Tayvon Gray, fresh off a red-card suspension. His presence in the backline will be vital for NYCFC, who know they’ll need nothing short of perfection to pull off a win.

But make no mistake, this isn’t just a ticket to the semifinals on the line. This battle has evolved into a clash of styles, strategies, and, undeniably, pride. Cincinnati, a former Supporters' Shield champ, wants to show the world that their regular-season success wasn’t some fluke; they’re here to make a legitimate title run. For NYCFC, it’s all about proving they can rise to the occasion, take on the heavyweights, and do it in a stadium where defeat has loomed large in the past.

For the coaches, striking the right balance between aggression and caution will be the ultimate test. Cincinnati’s head coach, Pat Noonan, has the home advantage and knows NYCFC’s weak spots all too well. Still, he’s fully aware that any slip-up could be deadly. Noonan’s team must keep up that aggressive mindset from Game 1, tempered by the knowledge that playoff overconfidence is a dangerous trap.

On the other side, NYCFC’s Nick Cushing has already proven he knows how to rally his squad, turning a team down on their luck into an absolute powerhouse in Game 2. Now, he’ll have to strike the perfect balance between boldness and restraint if he wants to avoid an early exit.