California Clásico and the Birth of Historic Rivalries in MLS

From day one, Major League Soccer (MLS) had been on a quest to find its identity, torn between trying to be Hollywood, Broadway—or maybe both. In the middle of this winding path, something that truly fired up fans was born: the California Clásico and the battle for titles fought tooth and nail.

Right off the bat in 2000, MLS gave fans a taste of novelty that would set the stage for future finals. Back then, Kansas City Wizards, a team that had never even come close to touching an MLS Cup trophy, went and did the unthinkable—beating Chicago Fire 1-0. Here was the classic underdog tale, a team starving for glory, knocking down one of the powerhouses of that era against all odds. That win was a sign of things to come, where, maybe, the favorite wouldn’t always be the one raising the cup.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

But from 2001 to 2004, the MLS Cup truly found its rhythm, and it all kicked off with the now-famous California Clásico. This period brought an intense rivalry between the Los Angeles Galaxy and the San Jose Earthquakes—two teams battling not just for the trophy but for California bragging rights. In 2001, these two giants clashed in the final, with Earthquakes emerging victorious, 2-1. And let’s not forget, this was the game where Landon Donovan arrived as a shining star. Picture this: a kid with an innocent face and legs of steel, bursting onto the scene and carving his name into MLS Cup history. This was the start of Donovan’s legend—the American hero primed to become the face of soccer in Uncle Sam's backyard.

The California rivalry intensified, but 2002 was when the MLS Cup hit an almost surreal note, like something straight out of a sports opera. Los Angeles Galaxy faced New England Revolution at Gillette Stadium, packed with over 61,000 roaring fans. And there, in this wild atmosphere of screams and sheer energy, Galaxy clinched their first title, defeating Revolution in overtime. Little did anyone know, this victory would start a painful trend for Revolution, turning them into the “almost champions” of future MLS finals.

Now, the 2003 final? That was a cinematic showdown where two heavyweights squared off to see who’d be left standing. Chicago Fire and San Jose Earthquakes met after dominating their respective conferences, fueling a clash filled with pure quality. The Fire were riding high with their Supporters’ Shield, while Earthquakes had rolled through the season with the second-best record. In the end, San Jose came out on top, 4-2, seizing their second title. This final was an all-out battle of attacks, calculated moves, and coaches pressing their squads to capitalize on every tiny misstep—a real showdown of giants.

But it wouldn’t be MLS without the dramatic comeback of a former champion. In 2004, D.C. United made their way back to the MLS Cup after a four-year hiatus, feeling like a club that knew its way back to victory. Their opponent? Kansas City Wizards, with the sweet memory of the 2000 title still fresh. From the start, this game was a wild ride, with four goals scored in just 25 minutes. Yet, it was United that held their ground, ending the game with a 3-2 score, raising their fourth trophy, while the Wizards were left on the edge of what could have been glory.