San Diego FC shocks MLS with Pablo Sisniega signing and raises big questions

The experienced goalkeeper joins a crowded roster but can he truly make a difference

D.C. United v Charlotte FC - Pre-Season Friendly
D.C. United v Charlotte FC - Pre-Season Friendly | Matthew Ashton - AMA/GettyImages

Meanwhile, San Diego FC is creating quite a stir in anticipation of its maiden season in Major League Soccer. The latest to become part of their roster is 29-year-old keeper Pablo Sisniega, with vast experience having played for LAFC, Charlotte FC, and, lately, San Antonio FC, for whom he won the USL title. His contract, through 2025 with options for 2026 and 2027, feels like a measured risk balanced between experience and promise.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Born in Mexico City, Sisniega has always had adaptability as his hallmark. Having worked at top academies such as Chivas Guadalajara, Philadelphia Union, and Real Sociedad, his technical repertoire is second to none. But after an encouraging start to life in Europe with 38 games and 14 clean sheets for Real Sociedad B, Sisniega really found his footing in MLS. With over 37 matches and 3,300 minutes under his belt, he's flashed brilliance but still has to shake off the burden of proving himself at the highest level.

The San Diego FC context

This is a league where every season the level of competitiveness rises, and thus there is no leeway to build up mediocre squads. San Diego FC, guided by head coach Mikey Varas, is not cutting corners. Adding Sisniega to a goalkeeper corps that already boasts Jacob Jackson, CJ dos Santos, and Duran Ferree — on loan with FC Nordsjælland until June — speaks to a very obvious strategy: internal competition elevates the standard. But with so many options between the posts, might this plethora of talent create more problems than it solves?

Strength or just stats?

Sisniega's experience is beyond repute, but his recent record is a little cause for concern. He has kept only five clean sheets in 33 appearances in MLS. In contrast, his performance in USL was way more convincing, having played a key role in the championship run of San Antonio FC. That contrast automatically raises the question of whether Sisniega is a safer mid-level league bet or if he can really be one of those game-changers within the high-stakes world of MLS. The confidence of San Diego's sporting director, Tyler Heaps: "Pablo brings depth and experience to a competitive group of goalkeepers joining us in January." But is depth enough to ensure success?

A competitive advantage

One big factor in his favor is that Sisniega has a U.S. Green Card-meaning he will not occupy an international roster spot. This is one deep strategic advantage, finally giving San Diego FC the freedom needed to focus their international slots on other critical positions. With every little edge important in such a competitive league, this flexibility could prove game-changing regarding wider roster planning by the club.

San Diego FC's gamble on Sisniega is an investment between pragmatism and optimism. With the MLS debut just around the corner, onlookers will be eager to see whether this experienced keeper rises to the challenge of nailing a spot in such a jam-packed lineup. As the countdown to February 2024 gets underway, one important question lingers: will Sisniega prove to be those steady hands that San Diego so desperately needs, or is he just another cog in a moving puzzle?