FC Cincinnati takes a risky gamble with Nicholas Gioacchini, but is It worth it?

FC Cincinnati decided to go bold. By bringing in Nicholas Gioacchini on loan from Como, the American club is trying to strengthen its attack with a player who carries both potential and uncertainty. After all, we’re talking about a guy who’s been around the globe but has yet to cement himself as a bona fide star. Will this gamble finally pay off?

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

Gioacchini, at 24, is the classic case of a player who always seems on the verge of breaking through but never quite nails it. He’s been with various clubs, like Orlando City SC and Montpellier HSC, where his performances have ranged from promising to underwhelming. His most recent stint was with Como in Italy, where he was part of the team’s promotion campaign to Serie A. But with just nine appearances, his impact on the field was limited, raising doubts about whether he can make a difference for a club that’s looking to rise in MLS.

And that’s exactly where the risk lies for FC Cincinnati. By opting for a loan deal without a purchase option, the club is playing a high-stakes game of chess. On one hand, they have the flexibility to assess Gioacchini without tying up their financial future in a long-term contract. On the other, they risk losing a player who, if he finally hits his stride, won’t be able to stay on the roster. It’s a delicate situation for the front office: if the forward shines, they’ll have to face the frustration of watching him leave without any guarantee of a return.

Looking at Gioacchini’s track record, it’s easy to understand the hesitation in going all-in on him. His 10 goals in 32 appearances for St. Louis City SC during the club’s inaugural MLS season show that he can be productive. However, his subsequent move to Como, followed by a campaign where he barely made an impact, pours cold water on the excitement. After all, if he couldn’t establish himself in a league like Italy’s Serie B, what can we expect from his performance in MLS?

But not everything is up in the air. Gioacchini also has his international credentials, having been called up to the USMNT and being part of the squad that won the 2021 CONCACAF Gold Cup. These experiences might give him the confidence needed to make a splash at FC Cincinnati.

The big question, though, is whether Gioacchini can handle the pressure. FC Cincinnati isn’t a club that can afford to miss on its signings. Every addition needs to be a perfect fit in the puzzle, capable of making an immediate and significant impact. With a temporary contract and no security of a purchase option, Gioacchini steps into a scenario where every game will be a trial by fire. He’ll need to prove his worth from the very first minute on the pitch, knowing that his future—both at the club and in his career—is on the line.

FC Cincinnati is playing its cards with a bit of daring. Bringing in Nicholas Gioacchini might be seen as a calculated gamble, an attempt to land the right player without committing to the long term. But this strategy also has its dark side: the possibility of seeing Gioacchini blossom only to lose him without any compensation. For a club seeking stability and growth in MLS, this could be a gamble too risky to take. Now, all that’s left is to wait and see if Gioacchini will be the ace Cincinnati needed or just another passing piece in a puzzle that’s still being put together.