Lucho Acosta, 2023 MLS MVP, has left the soccer world in shock after hinting that he might just have taken to the pitch for the last time in an FC Cincinnati jersey. Tearfully, after his team was eliminated by New York City FC in the 2024 Audi MLS Cup playoffs, Acosta hinted that no one knows if he will ever be with the club again. Since joining Cincy in 2021, the impact of Acosta has been enormous, raising this question: will we see Acosta don the jersey again next season?
Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).
The Uncertainty of an MVP
This may be the farewell with the club; we don't know," Acosta said as he departed the field, with words laced with drama about what might be next. At 30 years old, the Argentine has a contract in place with Cincinnati through 2026, with an option for 2027. His words speak to a doubt and frustration, though, as if he feels like he might have already given what he can to the club.
To fans, it sounded like a goodbye. It would appear that Acosta is ready to put his last stamp-the last act in a career that helped make Cincinnati competitive. But what drives a player so deeply intertwined with the club to think about a future outside Ohio? The Journey of a Leader
Acosta's arrival in 2021 proved to be a turning point for Cincinnati. A previously bottom-of-the-league club, the No. 10 brought new energy in the form of leadership and rhythm to the squad. Fast forward to 2023, where he played a major role in clinching the Supporters' Shield, guiding the team through the regular season to its best record.
Beyond titles, though, Acosta's impact becomes crystal clear. In this 2024 campaign alone, he has recorded a career-high 33 goal involvements-14 goals, 19 assists-and he is very valuable to the team. Over the last four years, he's tallied 48 goals and 62 assists, accounting for a crucial 51% of Cincy's goals from 2021 to now. What these numbers show is this: if Acosta leaves, then FC Cincinnati will have a problem on their hands.
Frustration and Future: An Open-Hearted Reflection
An visibly frustrated Acosta, after elimination, said, "I think I've given a lot," still disappointed from the season's end. That knockout on penalties to NYCFC after the scoreless draw felt like a heavy blow to this player, who until the last minute, wanted to take Cincinnati further.
But this frustration goes beyond the field: Acosta did say "personal things" and "behind-the-scenes matters" drove his decisions. Adding this really puts an element of intrigue on his desire for change not being only related to results on the pitch but also to internal dynamics and, perhaps, his personal life.
Legacy in Ohio?
Every time one thinks about Luciano Acosta at FC Cincinnati, one can't help but think of a player who has given his all to the club. He himself had said, "I want them to remember me this way. I gave my life for this club. I gave it everything. It's been amazing years." These words are the reflection of Acosta related to Cincinnati-a mix of gratitude and fulfillment, as if he truly feels he's left an indelible mark.
Acosta is concerned with his legacy. The fans should remember him not only as an MVP or a star, but forming part of the transformation of the club. He has been able to make so much impact that's beyond numbers, and he has resonated with the fans who consider him one of the greatest to ever wear the FC Cincinnati jersey.
What's Next for Acosta?
So, it would seem that Luciano Acosta's career depends on many factors, as he has even expressed himself. He has "thought about it for a while," and the last words he says-certainly not said as a goodbye-sound like a pause for reflection on what is truly the best for him and for the club. It means a very tough decision that he has to make, not only professionally but also personally and behind closed doors, as mentioned.
Thus, the stage seems set for an apparently possible goodbye to one of the more iconic players to grace Cincinnati's lineup in recent memory, and the question now is what's next on both sides. With new possible offers and growing visibility from around the league, Acosta's decision to stay or go may not be driven by anything more than a will to compete.