5 reasons Neymar joining Inter Miami could disrupt MLS as we know it

With the probable presence of Neymar, Inter Miami is shaking the world of MLS and creating mixed emotions in the minds of their supporters. While many are excited by the possibility of Neymar joining forces with Lionel Messi and Luis Suárez on perhaps the most high-profile squad in the league, others are worried this signing could "break the league." They argue that having the trio on Inter Miami would affect the competitive balance in placing the spotlight on a single club and tilt the dynamics of the MLS. Here are five reasons why the possible signing of Neymar to Inter Miami could be a gamble taken by the league.

Follow MLS Multiplex on X (Twitter).

1. Monopollization of Talent and Competitive Balance

With Neymar on board, Inter Miami would get an additional power surge on the pitch, teaming up with Messi and Suárez to form an unbeatable trio-for them, a victory. However, the rest of the MLS teams would probably face much difficulty trying to compete on an equal footing. The league works in a structure where there is balance among the teams so every single team has an equal opportunity to try their best for the championship title, also to attract viewers. With the "Inter Miami super team," all that can be ruined, leading to disparity between teams and putting other teams at big disadvantages.

And with Neymar coming into the mix, it would most definitely shrivel that opportunity to compete down to an all-time low. We would no longer have a league where many teams come forward to contest the title, but instead, this might be reduced to a "one-team race" where one pace is set by Inter Miami alone and thus dominated in every win. If that happens, such a league would surely turn dull even for fans of other teams to watch.

2. Overexposure of Media and Fan Attention to One Club

With Neymar, Messi, and Suárez all on one team, it would be impossible not to have media and fan attention skewed vastly in the direction of Inter Miami. As long as that is great news for the club, it runs a danger in respect of the league: the MLS does try to make space for all its franchises, allowing each team to grow and build its very own fan base. But with a super team hogging the limelight, smaller or less glamorous clubs fall by the wayside, losing their chance to gain visibility and fans.

It is relevant to the healthy growth of MLS that the league does not have to depend on one club for the crowd and media attraction. Conjecture of all attention on one single team runs the risk of creating, in substance, a "one-club league," banishing franchises to second-tier status-a worse outcome for the league as a whole. In the event that Inter Miami becomes the only extremely well-known club, MLS will be facing precisely what it does not want: less interest in other teams, with the fan base increasingly consolidated around one team.

3. Impact on Salary Cap System and Other Teams' Discontent

Inter Miami would need to rework their financial structure in order to fit Neymar onto their payroll. This might mean exceeding the MLS salary cap for this. The league has a very strict cost-control system, fundamentally targeted at preserving financial and competitive balance. Signing Neymar might require special allowances and exceptions to keep him within the league thus making them appear to be bending the rules for one team.

Accommodating him in this way is not only an economic problem but also a matter of sportsmanship. For other teams, it may seem like Inter Miami receives special treatment, thus causing them to become disgruntled and perhaps even lose faith in the system within the league. For a league priding itself on competitive balance, easing the salary cap rules to accommodate one player risks bringing in the perception of favoritism, which doesn't sit quite as well with other franchises and their fans.

4. Risk of Losing Fans from Other Teams

If Inter Miami is the center of attention, then the fans for the other teams will not be interested. For a fan of LA Galaxy or the New York Red Bulls, this automatically makes them know that most of the league concentration and resources go to Inter Miami, and thus they end up less interested, or even disconnected with the championship. After all, it is more than wins and losses; a fan wants to be attached with something he feels could give his favorite team an equal opportunity.

This unevenness of interest would result in an empty stadium and fewer viewership in the games that would not include Inter Miami. MLS, having struggled to develop a loyal fan base and build up its average attendance, will see those efforts undercut as interest diminishes in matches that don't include Inter Miami. That such a decline in interest would undermine the longer-term popular appeal of the league.

5. Overemphasis on Inter Miami Weakens the Identity of MLS

One of the major strengths of MLS is its identity, with teams that span cultures and communities and styles of play. Neymar's arrival at Inter Miami will only cement it as an "island of stars" and justifies the belief that Inter Miami is in a league of their own. Instead of building on the images of MLS as a whole, competitive league, having Neymar and Messi would make it seem like this is just a jumping-off point for that one "superior" club, taking the focus away from the league as a whole and diluting its identity in turn.

With Inter Miami being almost a "league within a league," only the biggest stars shine, while other teams follow a quieter, domestic path with much less media attention. MLS would lose this great opportunity to solidify itself as a truly unified competitive league composed of more teams that had the potential to attract worldwide fans.

Neymar and the Future of MLS: Another Club, Another Story?

For many, this would be show and tell to have Neymar next to Messi and Suárez, but with consequences nevertheless. Actually, Neymar going to a less central club would have the effect of strengthening the league in general, since other franchises stand out and become relevant for the development of MLS. Maybe Neymar going to another MLS team would balance it and make it more varied.

The question isn't if Neymar should come to MLS-he'd be a huge asset to the league-but rather where he should play. Instead of bunching the biggest stars at Inter Miami, it could spread them around the league to create a more complex and interesting environment for teams and fans, driving further competitiveness and interest while keeping MLS on its path toward sustainable, balanced growth.